Connect with us

NFL Draft

2017 NFL Draft: 5 Players Cowboys Should Avoid In Round One

Kevin Brady



2017 NFL Draft: 5 Players Cowboys Should Avoid In Round One

With some serious holes to address in the 2017 NFL Draft, the Dallas Cowboys still have a good shot at improving on their roster despite having such a late first round pick.

Considering both the depth of this draft class at positions of need and the Cowboys' ability to draft impact players since Will McClay effectively took over, Dallas should feel confident going into the final weekend of April.

If they are going to make the most of their first round pick, however, there are a few consensus first round players which I believe the Cowboys should avoid taking if possible.

Taco Charlton, EDGE, Michigan

Dallas Cowboys 2017 NFL Draft Target: Michigan DE Taco Charlton

Sorry, Michigan fans.

Defensive end Taco Charlton was a seriously productive pass rusher in college, and in my opinion will be a solid left defensive end at the next level. I currently have a second round grade on Charlton, and believe he can be a effective defensive lineman if in the right system and asked to do the right things.

With all that being said, there's no way I want the Cowboys to draft Taco Charlton with their first round pick.

Essentially, adding Charlton would be like adding another DeMarcus Lawrence. While I like Lawrence as a left defensive end, he is not the explosive edge rusher the Cowboys need right now.

Instead, I hope Dallas looks towards other EDGE prospects with a much more athletic profile, explosive pass rush, and higher ceiling as a right defensive end. (See Derek Rivers, TJ Watt, Carl Lawson, Takkarist McKinley, and Charles Harris)

Jabrill Peppers, Defensive Back, Michigan

2017 Cowboys Draft: Should Dallas Target Jabrill Peppers? 1

Let's keep the trend of annoying Michigan fans, okay?

Similar to Charlton, I actually like Jabrill Peppers as a player/athlete. He is a fun watch, and with time may be able to develop into a starting safety in the NFL.

He simply doesn't have it yet, however.

As a pure safety, Peppers has not shown enough to warrant a first round pick from any team, let alone a team like the Cowboys who would like to win now. He was successful playing in the box in college, but he doesn't seem to have the build or strength to do so in the NFL.

Basically, he's a tweener who doesn't have a true position at the moment. Given that, I wouldn't spend a first round pick on Jabrill Peppers, especially not with other talented safeties on the board.

Jalen "Teez" Tabor, Cornerback, Florida

Dallas Cowboys 2017 NFL Draft Target: Florida CB Teez Tabor

October 1, 2016:Florida Gators corner back Jalen Tabor (31) during a 13-6 win by Florida over Vanderbilt at Vanderbilt Stadium in Nashville, Tenn. (Photo by Jamie Gilliam/Icon Sportswire)

Oh how the mighty have fallen...

Teez Tabor seemed to be a sure-fire first round pick just a few months ago, but after absurdly poor testing at both the combine and his pro day, Tabor has fallen far down draft boards.

While fellow staff writer Sean Martin is still willing to die on the Teez Tabor hill, the fact that it's nearly impossible to find corners which deserved to be taken in round one with a 4.7 40 time, makes me think it's fair to have reservations about Tabor at 28.

With the abundance of talent this year's cornerback class possesses, I think we can find a corner who's tape matches better with their testing than Tabor's does in either of the first two rounds.

Obi Melifonwu, Safety, UCONN

Could Byron Jones Be Working Out With Barry Church's Replacement?

Speaking of players who's tape doesn't match their testing, let's discuss Obi Melifonwu.

Once again, I like Obi, I really do. I just don't like him enough to take him at 28. I currently have a late second round grade on Melifonwu, but if I was grading just on tape, he would slide back into the early third for me.

While his combine testing and athletic profiles are off the charts, Melifonwu simply doesn't show enough consistency as a safety to merit a first round pick.

Of course, he has drawn comparisons to current Cowboys safety and his former UCONN teammate Byron Jones based off their athletic profiles, but there is one big difference between the two.

Byron Jones had first round tape. I don't think Obi Melifonwu does.

Ryan Ramczyk, Offensive Tackle, Wisconsin

2017 NFL Draft: 5 Players Cowboys Should Avoid In Round One 1

This is less of an indictment on Ryan Ramczyk as it is the fact that I don't think the Cowboys should go offensive tackle in round one. But still, if they were to go tackle, I'd rather see Alabama's Cam Robinson be the pick here.

Ramczyk's draft status has been elevated a ton over the last few months, but his injury history and lack of experience really do worry me if I was going to take him in the first round.

I currently have a second round grade on Ramcyzk, and would not be opposed to selecting him with the 60th overall pick, but I don't believe the Cowboys need to reach for a tackle in round one considering all of their pressing defensive needs.

Die-hard Cowboys fan from the Northeast, so you know I am here to defend the 'boys whenever necessary. Began writing for a WordPress Cowboys Blog, and have been with ITS since 2016.



  1. Kevin Black

    April 6, 2017 at 10:01 am

    I agree with just about everything you say here. I’d add Takk McKinley to this list. His lack of agility is worrying. I’d put a 2nd round grade on him as well. His 3-Cone and Shuttle times were very concerning.

    • Kevin Brady

      Kevin Brady

      April 6, 2017 at 2:04 pm

      Takk McKinley is an interesting case. He is so raw that I think Marinelli could help teach him how to rush the passer and use all of those athletic tools to his advantage. At the same time, his lack of agility and shoulder issues do worry me in round one.

  2. Olivier Stewart

    April 6, 2017 at 11:29 am

    I thought this was a good scouting report on Jabrill Peppers, thoughts?

    The film room Ep. 29: Jabrill Peppers Scouting Report

    • Kevin Brady

      Kevin Brady

      April 6, 2017 at 2:06 pm

      To be honest, that video is the best case for Peppers I have seen so far. Still, I have significant questions about him being a top 50 player in this class.

  3. Randy Martin

    April 6, 2017 at 12:26 pm

    I don’t understand the Obi love. They have fallen in love with the way he looks and his combine performance and everybody just jumped on the buzz about the guy. I think Brugler has about 9 safeties in front of him. He is definitely not a round 1 guy. There have not been many 6’4 safeties that were successful.

    • Kevin Brady

      Kevin Brady

      April 6, 2017 at 2:05 pm

      I agree, Randy. He is an incredible athlete and could be an interesting day two prospect, but I can’t endorse taking him in the first round.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

NFL Draft

Cowboys Draft Target: Kentucky CB Lonnie Johnson Jr.

Kevin Brady



Cowboys Draft Target: Kentucky CB Lonnie Johnson Jr.

Since Kris Richard has taken over the back-end of the Dallas Cowboys defense, they have clearly shown a bias towards a "type" of cornerback. Richard, looking to build this Dallas unit in a similar form to his Seattle teams, has prioritized long corners both in height and arm length.

As his responsibilities within the organization increase, it's only fair to expect Kris Richard to have more say in who the Cowboys' defense acquires in terms of talent. This means we should anticipate more defensive backs who fit his type, such as Kentucky Wildcats cornerback Lonnie Johnson Jr.

The Player

So why does Lonnie Johnson fit the mold of what Kris Richard tends to look for? Well, for starters, he is 6'3" and 206 lbs with 32 1/4" arms. He's a long corner with excellent size and the trait profile which indicates he could be the perfect candidate to play cornerback in Dallas.

But while he might look great on paper, the tape is always the most important factor for evaluating and projecting talent. And, for Johnson, the tape isn't all-that great. Despite his length, Johnson struggled mightily in press-man coverage at Kentucky. Too often he is late or ineffective with his hands, leaving him susceptible to being blown by by the opposing receiver. He often loses balance due to poor footwork, and is rather average with his hips and quick change of direction.

Where Johnson was his best in college was in zone coverage, playing his deep third of Kentucky's cover-three look. Rarely did he allow receivers behind him in zone coverage, and displayed good instincts when deciding whether to jump routes or play more conservatively when playing in that deep third. He was not nearly as comfortable underneath, and Kentucky didn't ask him to play in that role too often. Because of how big he is, Johnson is able to contest at the catch point regularly, yet he only deflected 9 passes in 2 years.

What gives me the most hope for Lonnie Johnson as a prospect (besides his length) is his Senior Bowl performance. Johnson impressed daily at the Senior Bowl, looking more comfortable in man coverage and playing much better in his press technique.

Was this Johnson becoming more comfortable over time and a sign of things to come at the next level, or was it an anomaly that we shouldn't read too much into? The answer to that question is up to the individual teams, but his combine performance will play a huge role in how those teams answer.

The Fit

As I've discussed already, Lonnie Johnson Jr. fits what Kris Richard tends to look for in his cornerbacks. He is long, tall, and relatively athletic, making him a clay piece for a coach like Richard to develop.

The question is, however, how much development can really occur? The highs for Johnson are rather high when he maximizes his natural abilities on the field. But too often he is sloppy in technique, or looks lost in man coverage. Whether or not Richard can "fix" Johnson completely may never be seen, but teams (especially this one) could fall in love with him as a prospect for what he can become if it all comes together.

Continue Reading

NFL Draft

Cowboys Draft Target: Oklahoma Sooners RB Rodney Anderson

Brian Martin



Cowboys Draft Target: Oklahoma Sooners RB Rodney Anderson

NAME: Rodney Anderson

SCHOOL: Oklahoma


POSITION: Running Back

CLASS: RS Junior

JERSEY: No. 24


HT: 6'1"

WT: 219

D.O.B.: 9/12/96


Rodney Anderson || 2017-18 Highlights ᴴᴰ || Oklahoma

Rodney Anderson || 2017-18 Highlights ᴴᴰ || Oklahoma Like, Comment, and Subscribe for More! Follow my Instagram: @szhighlights Songs: - "Don't Know Me" by Trae Tha Truth - "Better Days" by Trae Tha Truth I do not own any of these highlights or music clips.

Before we get into the player, we should really try to get to know Rodney Anderson the person. He attended Katy High School in Katy, Texas, one of the powerhouse HS football programs in the state. He was a four-star recruit who received offers from Auburn, Baylor, Texas A&M, and Oklahoma. He originally committed to Texas A&M, but changed his mind and decided to go to Oklahoma instead. He had an up-and-down career on the football field at Oklahoma because of injuries, but did graduate with a degree in Arts and Sciences in May 2018 and is pursuing his Master's in Human Relations.


Rodney Anderson has the ideal size and athleticism to become a featured back in the NFL. He shows good patience and vision on film to allow his offensive lineman to secure their blocks before sticking his foot in the ground and exploding through the hole. He runs behind his pads and shows good strength, loose hips, and balance to run through arm tackles. More than capable of picking up those "dirty yards" and is surprisingly slippery as a runner in the open field.

Anderson is capable of playing in a power scheme or a zone heavy scheme like the Dallas Cowboys deploy. He has been featured in a number of rushing concepts including gap/power, read action, and power sweeps. His talent also carries over to the passing game. He possesses soft hands and looks natural catching the ball both out of the backfield and down the field as a receiver. Solid in pass protection, but this is an area of his game where he can improve.


The biggest negative about Rodney Anderson is his injury history at Oklahoma. He is basically a one-year wonder because of three separate season-ending injuries, but bad things happen in three so maybe that's behind him. Durability will be a question mark entering the NFL though.

His vision is sometimes questionable, especially on inside and outside zone reads. Has a tendency to to try to bounce runs to the outside too often or cut back too quickly. Shows good explosiveness, but only average burst through the hole. Seems to have adequate long speed on tape, but is 40 yard dash time will be heavily scrutinized if he's able to run at the NFL Scouting Combine.

In the passing game he needs to improve his route running and pass protection if he wants to be a three-down back in the NFL. The talent is there, just not the production and consistency. Will also have to prove he can be productive against stacked boxes at the next level since he rarely saw any in college due to Oklahoma's spread offense.

Cowboys Fit:

If the Dallas Cowboys are looking for a running back capable of being a featured back in the NFL, while also spelling Ezekiel Elliott from time to time, then Rodney Anderson is there guy. His combination of power, balance, explosiveness, and scheme diversity could come in handy as their RB2. Not only would he provide a good insurance policy if the unthinkable were to happen to Zeke, but he could take over if they decide not to give No. 21 a contract extension.

There is a lot to like about Rodney Anderson's game and his ability to contribute in the running and passing game, but he is not by any means a clean prospect. Despite his immense talent, his injury history and lack of consistency in college is bothersome. But, as a mid-round pick the reward far outweighs the risks. Paired with Elliott, the Cowboys could have a formidable one-two punch in their backfield and could pound opposing defenses into submission.

Continue Reading

NFL Draft

Cowboys Draft Target: South Carolina WR Deebo Samuel

Kevin Brady



Cowboys Draft Target: South Carolina WR Deebo Samuel

Our search for a new pass catcher for the Cowboys in this years' draft class continues, this time with a wide receiver.

South Carolina's Deebo Samuel put himself on the map with a strong Sophomore season, but fell off a bit due to a severe leg injury early in 2017. After a strong 2018 campaign, and an impressive performance at the Senior Bowl, Samuel has played himself back into early Day Two draft discussions.

The Player

I don't know that anyone "won" Senior Bowl week more than Deebo Samuel did this January. Samuel, who had to deal with some poor quarterback play throughout his college career, didn't get much of a break in that department either at the Senior Bowl. But, he did show out every day at practice, and seemed to go viral on Twitter at least once a day.

During his actual collegiate season, Samuel finished with 882 yards and 11 touchdowns on 62 catches, solid production especially coming off an injury and playing in a limited offense. Initially in the NFL, Samuel is going to make his money in the slot. He's a shifty yet explosive receiver type than can quickly beat defenders with his speed. He's not the speedster than someone like Marquise Brown is, but he is explosive enough in his own right, especially in terms of short-area quickness.

Samuel isn't someone who will go up and grab the ball consistently, or even make up for inaccurate throws as often as some others might be able to. But he does have reliable hands, and his ability to get open quickly and create separation should give someone like Dak Prescott easy windows to find him in for completions.

What makes Deebo Samuel so fun for me to watch, though, is his ability after the catch. Despite his lack of size, Samuel is tough as nails, and rarely defers out of bounds or avoids contact. He's built well enough to withstand that contact as well, and when he gets free, he's hard to catch and bring down.

The Fit

Drafting Deebo Samuel 58th overall would be a heck of a haul for the Dallas Cowboys. In need of another playmaker in the passing game, the Cowboys could make immediate use of Samuel's talents in 2019, specifically as a slot receiver.

As has been mentioned ad nauseam, it seems unlikely that Cole Beasley will be returning to the team this season, which makes the need for a slot wide-out that much greater. Samuel has big play ability from the slot already, and has traits which project him to potentially work outside as well. If he tests well enough at the combine, reps on the outside could very well be in his future.

Samuel should be on every Cowboys fans' shortlist of draft targets in the second round this year.

Continue Reading

Enjoy 40% commissions on officially licensed products as a FanPrint affiliate. You can even make your own, fully licensed Cowboys and player designs! Get started here