I think you can tier the guys together based on how you want to resign them.

Tier 1(Must Re-Sign)
Gregory, Kearse, Anger

Tier 2(Luxury but not necessity)
Schultz, Armstrong, Neal, LVE, Hooker, Kazee, Gallup, Wilson

Tier 3(Take it or Leave it)
Williams, Turner, Brown, Sprinkle, Nysekhe, Watkins, Urban, McQuaide

Tier 4(Easily replaceable)
Clement, Hyatt, Bernard, Gifford, Canady