Connect with us

Dallas Cowboys

The Curse of Larry Allen; Cowboys Have Ugly 2nd Round Draft History

Jess Haynie

Published

on

Larry Allen

The Cowboys have had over two decades of problems with their second-round picks in the NFL Draft. For the last 22 years they have struggled to find solid contributors, let alone standout players, from among the upper layers of available talent. It is a disturbing trend that, hopefully, will soon see a reversal.

In the second round of the 1994 NFL Draft, the Dallas Cowboys selected guard Larry Allen from little Sonoma State University. Allen would go on to become arguably the greatest guard in NFL history, inducted to the Ring of Honor and the Hall of Fame.

Perhaps the Larry Allen pick was the Cowboys doom. It's almost like the universe has been punishing them ever since for getting such a legendary player with a second-round pick.

As this following historical record shows, our second round additions since L.A. have been nothing short of ugly.

1995 RB Sherman Williams
TE Kendell Watkins
G Shane Hannah
1996 KB Randall Godfrey
DE Kavika Pittman
1997 NO PICK - Traded out of the 2nd Round for extra picks later
1998 OT Flozell Adams
1999 G Solomon Page
2000 CB Dwayne Goodrich
2001 QB Quincy Carter
S Tony Dixon
2002 G/C Andre Gurode
WR Antonio Bryant
2003 G/C Al Johnson
2004 RB Julius Jones
OT Jacob Rogers
2005 LB Kevin Burnett
2006 TE Anthony Fasano
2007 NO PICK - Traded out of the 2nd Round for extra picks later
2008 TE Martellus Bennett
2009 NO PICK - Traded out of the 2nd Round for extra picks later
2010 LB Sean Lee
2011 LB Bruce Carter
2012 NO PICK - Traded to move up for Morris Claiborne
2013 TE Gavin Escobar
2014 DE DeMarcus Lawrence
2015 DE Randy Gregory
2016 LB Jaylon Smith

Ready for some disturbing numbers?

Out of the 24 total second-round players drafted by Dallas since 1995, only three of them (Flozell Adams, Andre Gurode, Sean Lee) have ever gone to the Pro Bowl as Cowboys. That is a stunningly low number given the perceived talent that these guys all had on draft day.

It gets worse. Of the 21 players drafted from 1995 to 2013, a seven of them never even finished their rookie contracts. Another ten guys played out their four-year rookie deals and were not re-signed.

Only the three Pro Bowlers we just mentioned had sustained careers in Dallas with new contracts. The one oddball was Sherman Williams, who was re-signed due to injuries in 1999 and appeared in one game before being released again.

Think about that. We view the second round as the spot where potential stars and solid, long-time starters are drafted. By that standard the Cowboys have failed on almost 90% of their picks over the last two decades.

Randy Gregory

DE Randy Gregory, drafted in the second round of 2015.

Recent History

We have three second-round guys still on the team whose stories aren't fully written yet: DeMarcus Lawrence, Randy Gregory, and Jaylon Smith. Unfortunately, the early chapters are not looking good.

Other than a stretch in 2015 when he had seven sacks in eight games, Lawrence has been a disappointment. He has struggled with injuries and missed 18 games in three years. Now entering the final year of his rookie contract, D-Law will need a major improvement to avoid becoming yet another second-round Cowboy who didn't get a second contract.

The tale of Randy Gregory is certainly the most woeful. Injuries limited him as a rookie and a drug suspension knocked him out of most of 2016. He is expected to miss all of the 2017 regular season for a repeated drug policy violation. The Cowboys have not cut ties yet, though, so it remains to be seen if he can get things turned around.

Jaylon Smith was a top-five talent in the 2016 draft who fell because of a major knee injury during his last college game. He is expected to debut this year and has the potential to become one of the few bright spots in the team's history with second-round picks. If Jaylon's knee remains a problem, though, it could quickly become yet another failed attempt.

Fabian Moreau

CB Fabian Moreau is a potential 2nd-round target.

2017 NFL Draft

It is widely expected that in this year's draft, which occurs just a few days from now, Dallas will pursue a defensive end in the first round and a cornerback in the second. Players like Washington's Kevin King, Florida's Teez Tabor, and UCLA's Fabian Moreau are among the possible options for the Cowboys at the 60th overall pick.

In what is widely considered a deep draft class, and especially at cornerback, one of these players will have a great opportunity to be a success story. They will be joining a Cowboys team coming off a 13-3 season and putting the pieces in place for sustained success. Many of our past rookies weren't so fortunate, joining the team when it was in a state of flux or even dysfunction.

As we've seen with franchises like the Browns and Jaguars, that constant culture of failure rubs off on players. They are expected to be part of the solution but, young and impressionable, quickly become part of the problem. There's nobody there to teach them how to become winners.

The Cowboys have leaders on both sides of the ball. They have one of the most respected defensive coordinators in the game. Dallas has been to the playoffs twice in the last three years. If the rookies they add in 2017 don't show up then it's probably on them far more than the organization.

Or, if nothing else... blame Larry Allen.



Cowboys fan since 1992, blogger since 2011. Bringing you the objectivity of an outside perspective with the passion of a die-hard fan. I love to talk to my readers, so please comment on any article and I'll be sure to respond!

Advertisement
2 Comments
  • deal with it

    15 years later we are still paying for Jerrah’s carp………
    no money for FA,draft sucking this year, and no cap to trade……..I truly expect 10-6 ALL on Dak’s shoulders & that’s not fair.
    we’re getting jack diddly in this draft………….calling it now.
    love Taco but a taco ain’t a meal- calling it again.
    @ LEAST he can pass a UA………..

  • dcoopthemann

    Just came across this article. And although I know it’s only meant to be somewhat comical about a Larry Allen curse, the sad fact is it’s true in regards to second round picks. As a Cowboys fan since 1974 and who has followed them in detail (front office moves, the draft, etc.) since 1978, I thought I was the only one or one of the only ones who noticed this horrible second round draft record. And they should be ashamed of themselves for it. And people, especially Cowboy fans walk around like that are “SHOCKED” they haven’t been to a Super Bowl, let alone won one since this “TREND” has started. But I ask anyone, name any team at any point in their history that has had a draft “Drought” in one round for that long, for that many years straight in their history? The real sad part about it for me is, for the most part, 90% to 95% of the players on this “ALL STAR” list, I “KNEW” wasn’t going to be nothing and I remember every draft, Jerry Jones and yes, Stephen Jones was high fiving each other every draft like a couple of frat boys who scored with all the cheerleaders. Man, was it sickening to watch. That’s why I always say, the last time I thought the Cowboys were a Super Bowl team was 1996, which lines up almost perfectly with when the “ALL STAR” line-up started (my 1996 Super Bowl win was based on Aikman, Emmitt, Irvin, Deion, Hailey, etc., not any of the draft picks during this time) When these players got older or injured, I “KNEW” it was “OVER”. And only since 2014 have i seen any “HINT” it might start to change.

Dallas Cowboys

Which Cowboys Benefit From David Irving’s Suspension?

Jess Haynie

Published

on

David Irving

While losing David Irving for the first four weeks of 2018 is a bad thing for the Dallas Cowboys defensive line, it does create opportunities for some of the other defensive tackles. Who has the most to gain from Irving's suspension?

Because he was mostly going to be used inside as the 3-technique DT, David's absence will naturally benefit the guys who are best suited to play that role. Thankfully, Dallas isn't lacking for those types of players.

Veteran Tyrone Crawford can use all the playing time he can get. As a likely salary cap casualty next year, Crawford doesn't want to get buried on the depth chart as Dallas focuses on their younger players who project to stick around beyond 2018.

With Irving out, Dallas will likely lean on Tyrone as they often do when someone is missing on the defensive line. With more talent now at defensive end, Crawford was going to be competing with Irving, Maliek Collins, Jihad Ward, and other younger guys for work at tackle.

But now there's a problem, and it's easy to slide Crawford into the 3-tech role that Dallas once envisioned him being a star at. Remember, it was their projection of Tyrone as a breakout DT that got him his big contract to begin with.

Yes, Irving's only gone for four weeks. Dallas will still be giving him work in camp based on the role he should fill for the majority of the season. But that's why a veteran like Tyrone Crawford is a great temporary plug-in, because he doesn't need all of the practice reps to step in and perform.

Maliek Collins

Dallas Cowboys DT Maliek Collins

Another key beneficiary could be third-year DT Maliek Collins. Last season, Collins got stuck playing 1-technique and not getting the same opportunities to make plays and get noticed that he had his rookie year.

But now Dallas has several guys in Jihad Ward, Richard Ash, and Brian Price who can play the 1-tech role, which will hopefully get Collins back where he belongs. Maliek's athleticism belongs a little further away from center, letting him try to take on guards in single coverage.

Collins is dealing with a foot issue now but should be back for the preseason. That's enough time for him to be where he needs to be Week One, provided he's healthy.

How Dallas would balance playing time between Collins and Tyrone Crawford could be a matter of how much they play certain schemes. One could see Collins, the bigger guy, playing more in the base defense and then Crawford being used in passing situations.

There is always a lot of rotation in a Rod Marinelli line, so discussions about playing time can get a little silly. Unless you're a true stud like DeMarcus Lawrence who you don't want to take off the field, the Cowboys like to keep guys fresh.

But that's why this is a big opportunity; David Irving has that stud potential. He's the kind of talent who could keep solid players like Crawford and Collins out of view if he hits his stride.

For the first four weeks, though, Irving will be in the NFL doghouse and Dallas will likely lean on its two most experienced defensive tackles to fill the void. There will be more reps for guys like Datone Jones and Jihad Ward too, but Crawford and Collins have way more skins on the wall

That trust should keep them on the field more while David Irving's suspended, and perhaps beyond.



Continue Reading

Player News

BREAKING: David Irving Suspended For 2nd Consecutive Year

Mauricio Rodriguez

Published

on

David Irving

For the second consecutive year, Defensive Lineman David Irving is being suspended for four games by the NFL. This time, the suspension comes after Irving violated the NFL's policy on substance of abuses, as Ian Rapoport reported.

Ian Rapoport on Twitter

Cowboys DL David Irving is being suspended 4 games for violating @NFL policy on substance of abuses, sources say. Another big-time D-linemen hit with a suspension for Dallas.

Irving will play for the Dallas Cowboys after the team placed a second-round tender on him earlier in the year. Why no team was interested in picking such a talented defensive tackle for a second round pick is becoming clearer and clearer as the time goes on.

In April, when David Irving got hacked by his former girlfriend one of the tweets that stood out the most was one which said "Wait until you all find about his failed drug tests." Now, we're seeing what the tweet was about.

Irving is a very talented player that could have a great career ahead of him. Of course, with this being the second consecutive year in which he receives a suspension to start the season, one could question how much he wants it.

The Cowboys will play the Panthers, Giants, Seahawks and Lions to start the season. They'll have to do it with one of their most promising defensive players in David Irving.

Here at Inside The Star, we'll keep you updated with this story and every Dallas Cowboys news.

Tell me what you think about "BREAKING: David Irving Suspended For 2nd Consecutive Year" in the comments below, or tweet me @PepoR99 and let’s talk football! If you like football and are looking for a Dallas Cowboys show in Spanish, don’t miss my weekly Facebook Live! show, Primero Cowboys!



Continue Reading

Dallas Cowboys

Cowboys Offense Finds Rhythm to End Minicamp, Hurns and Gallup Stand Out

Sean Martin

Published

on

Cowboys Offense Finds Rhythm to End Minicamp, Hurns and Gallup Stand Out 1

The Dallas Cowboys are back in offseason mode, concluding their OTAs and minicamp from The Star. With a hiatus until training camp, it was important for several high-profile players to make a strong first impression on the 2018 season. From the start of mini camp, these impressions were left mostly by Rod Marinelli's defense and -- more specifically -- Kris Richard's young group of cornerbacks.

Still working through significant change on the offensive side of the ball, the Cowboys did rally on day three under Quarterback Dak Prescott to put out a better performance. The Cowboys coaching staff should love their lasting memories of both FA acquisition Wide Receiver Allen Hurns and rookie Michael Gallup.

There is a strong chance that these two receivers will be the Cowboys starters in Oxnard for training camp. We have heard a lot about the impact new WR Coach Sanjay Lal has had on his group, slowing the game down to focus on route running. This will give the team's rotation of unproven receivers a chance with Prescott, as he can focus on throwing to a 'spot' more often.

One spot that Prescott has struggled to hit in two seasons as the starter in Dallas is the back of the end zone for fade routes. A red zone go-to under Scott Linehan, free agent WR Dez Bryant was often the intended target on these missed passes.

Cowboys Offense Finds Rhythm to End Minicamp, Hurns and Gallup Stand Out

Dallas Cowboys WR Allen Hurns

Less of a route running technician and closer to the mold of a physical player like Bryant, Allen Hurns emerging as the Cowboys #1 option would solve a lot of uncertainty at the WR position. In yesterday's practice, Hurns was able to haul in a perfect ball from Prescott on the fade as he beat Byron Jones.

It's going to take some time for Jones to readjust to playing cornerback, but the vision for Kris Richard of him and Chidobe Awuzie starting on the outside is a great one. In a battle of proven players, Hurns got the best of Jones to spark the Cowboys offense at the right time.

Overall, there should be no reason to panic about (well, really anything from mini camp) the Cowboys offense right now, and plenty of reasons to be excited about what this defense will develop into.

Once the pads come on at training camp, the players the Cowboys are paying to play at an elite level will start to shine, including their newly re-signed Guard Zack Martin -- the highest paid guard in the league now. There are no doubts that the bread and butter for this offense will be handing the ball to Ezekiel Elliott behind this wall of an offensive line.

From this increase in competition in the trenches, we'll also get more meaningful battles along the defensive line. In shorts and helmets for now, the Cowboys secondary was given their chance at mini camp, and came out solid early.

Another player they've struggled to truly corral though is Michael Gallup. Perhaps pressing a bit thanks to his limited opportunities thus far, Jourdan Lewis was taken across the field by Gallup on a misfire from Cooper Rush.

This is nothing new for Gallup however, who's been ahead of the curve on creating the desired separation as a "violent" receiver on the outside.

A steal with the 81st overall pick in this year's draft, Gallup has a long way to go in beating out the likes of Terrance Williams, Cedrick Wilson (limited through this portion of the offseason with injuries), and even Cole Beasley, who's received some reps on the outside.

With both Hurns and Gallup making plays on the Cowboys final practice until late July, it's easy to let the mind wander with possibilities of the Cowboys offense playing at full strength against a defense that might be up for the challenge better than ever compared to year's past.

As always, the practice fields of Oxnard will serve as a battle ground for a young but deep Cowboys team to earn their spots on the 53-man roster, one that surely won't have room for all of the wide receiver hopefuls seen this week in mini camp.

Tell us what you think about "Cowboys Offense Finds Rhythm to End Minicamp, Hurns and Gallup Stand Out" in the comments below. You can also email me at Sean.Martin@InsideTheStar.com, or Tweet to me at @SeanMartinNFL!



Continue Reading

Reader Survey

Want to help make Inside The Star better?

We’re collecting feedback from our readers about the site. It only takes <2 minutes to complete, and can be done from any device.

> Take the survey now

Don’t worry, your information will not be shared with anyone but me (Bryson T.).




Enjoy 40% commissions on officially licensed products as a FanPrint affiliate. You can even make your own, fully licensed Cowboys and player designs! Get started here

Trending