Connect with us

Star Blog

Emmitt Stands Above Aikman, Irvin in Fan Poll

I recently saw a conversation between Cowboys fans that involved a passionate, unyielding defense of Emmitt Smith as the greatest running back of all time. It went beyond just the stats; Emmitt’s defender spoke about his character, endurance, and love for the game. He would’ve made any member of Cowboys Nation proud. It got me thinking about the way we remember the Cowboys of the 90s, and particularly the Triplets.  I’ve been a Dallas fan since 1993 and I’ve heard that same defense of Emmitt many times.

Jess Haynie

Published

on

Emmitt Smith

I recently saw a conversation between Cowboys fans that involved a passionate, unyielding defense of Emmitt Smith as the greatest running back of all time. It went beyond just the stats; Emmitt's defender spoke about his character, endurance, and love for the game. He would've made any member of Cowboys Nation proud.

Cowboys Headlines - Emmitt Stands Above Aikman, Irvin in Fan Poll 1It got me thinking about the way we remember the Cowboys of the 90s, and particularly the Triplets.  I've been a Dallas fan since 1993 and I've heard that same defense of Emmitt many times. What's interesting is that you will rarely hear fans defend Troy Aikman or Michael Irvin with the same passion.

In fact, I don't think I've ever heard any Cowboys fans say that Aikman or Irvin were the all-time best at their positions. What's more, I've rarely heard anyone propose that they were even the best players in just the 1990s. Why such a difference for one Triplet versus the other two?

I figured I'd collect some data. So, from my own Twitter handle @CowboysAddicts, I ran the following polls:

Jess Haynie on Twitter

Was Troy Aikman the best quarterback of the 1990s? #CowboysNation

Jess Haynie on Twitter

Was Michael Irvin the best wide receiver of the 1990s? #CowboysNation

Jess Haynie on Twitter

Was Emmitt Smith the best running back of the 1990s? #CowboysNation

 

As you'll note, I narrowed the field to just the 90s. Still, Emmitt is clearly held in a higher regard than Troy or Michael. Why is that? Is it fair?

Part of it is certainly statistics. As you well know, Emmitt is the NFL's all-time leader in rushing yardage. Comparatively, Aikman is 32nd in passing yardage and Irvin is 25th in receiving yards.

emmitt-smith-dallas-cowboys-ftrIn touchdowns, Aikman is 65th all-time among QBs and Irvin is tied for 52nd among WRs. In an even more glaring difference between them and Smith, Emmitt is the again the career leader in RB touchdowns and in second-place among players from all positions. In first place is Jerry Rice, who we'll talk about again shortly.

Obviously, a major reason for the lowers numbers for Aikman and Irvin is that high number for Emmitt. The Cowboys didn't have to pass in the redzone because of their great offensive line and Emmitt's toughness. I don't think this term was around back in the 90s, but Emmitt was a supreme touchdown "vulture" for anyone who had Troy or Michael on their fantasy teams.

Stats are great, but we know that what really mattered to these guys were the championships. All of them won three Super Bowls together. Troy and Emmitt each claimed a Super Bowl MVP from the back-to-back titles.

Dismissing Michael Irvin seems to the be the easiest of the three. Jerry Rice stands out so dominantly among all receivers that there's not much argument to be made. Tim Brown put up huge numbers for the Raiders. Though he only entered the league in 1998, some might even make a case for Randy Moss over The Playmaker.

Cowboys Headlines - Emmitt Stands Above Aikman, Irvin in Fan Poll 3It's the difference in respect for Troy Aikman that I find more interesting. We define quarterbacks by Super Bowls far more than any other position. Aikman was the only QB to win three of them in the 90s. Still, you'll often see guys with no rings like Dan Marino and Jim Kelly mentioned in higher esteem than Troy.

I'm not saying Aikman was the best of the 90s, either. As much as it pains me to say it because of the Boys-Niners rivalry of that decade, my pick would be Steve Young. No QB  from that era could take over a game like Young or had a better mix of accuracy and mobility.

I'm not saying there's any right or wrong to this stuff. Every fan has their own priorities and parameters for greatness, and that's a good thing. We wouldn't be able to have the fun conversations and debates otherwise.

Hopefully this sparks some conversation for you, our wonderful Inside The Star readers. Please comment below or via Twitter, Facebook, Google Plus, or whatever platform you use to follow us.



Cowboys fan since 1992, blogger since 2011. Bringing you the objectivity of an outside perspective with the passion of a die-hard fan. I love to talk to my readers, so please comment on any article and I'll be sure to respond!

Advertisement
Comments

Star Blog

Will It Be The Cowboys, Or Another Team, Who Pays Byron Jones After 2019?

Kevin Brady

Published

on

Cowboys Headlines -  81

After having his fifth year option exercised for the 2019 season, cornerback Byron Jones enters a contract year this Fall.

Jones inarguably had the best year of his career in 2018: earning not only his first Pro Bowl selection but also Second Team All Pro honors for his performance. Doing it all without an impressive stat sheet, Jones was able to let his film speak for itself throughout most of the year, and he became the number one cornerback we'd all hoped he could be when the Cowboys decided to take the freakishly athletic defensive back in the first round of the 2015 NFL Draft.

This contract year is quite unique for Byron Jones, however. Next offseason the Cowboys will be forced to re-sign and extend just about all of their key contributors on both sides of the ball. DeMarcus Lawrence already got his contract, but Dak Prescott, Ezekiel Elliott, Amari Cooper, and others still await their deals. Deals which the front office has all-but explicitly promised will come.

This leaves Jones, the former first round pick and now former All Pro, generally considered to be the odd man out. So while 2019 is a contract year for Byron Jones, he may be earning himself a contract from a completely different team.

Jones has had an interesting road to this contract season. One which would be a shame for the Cowboys to waste. Moving between cornerback and safety during the first three years of his career, Jones fell out of the coaches' good graces while playing out of his most natural position. Under Kris Richard's new regime, though, Jones had his best season to date. He looked to finally be comfortable in his role, and was now playing for a coach who believed he could be a special player.

Now that Byron Jones has found his place in the Cowboys defense, and has earned his way into conversations with the league's top cornerbacks, he's likely priced himself out of the Cowboys' future plans.

It's funny how that works out. Of course, Jones should go get paid, and I'd never fault a guy for maximizing his value on the market. But there's a good chance the Cowboys make the mistake of allowing a premier cornerback to walk out of their building next offseason. But if they want to retain players like Elliott and Cooper, they may not have any other choice.



Continue Reading

Star Blog

Will 2019 be the Storybook Ending to Jason Witten’s Hall of Fame Career?

Brian Martin

Published

on

Is Jason Witten Looking At A Lesser Role In 2017?

It's old news now, but Jason Witten will suit up for the Dallas Cowboys once again in 2019. After less than a year in retirement, he will return to the field with the hopes of chasing down that ever elusive Super Bowl ring that has eluded him, and the Cowboys, for nearly two decades. If successful, it would be the storybook ending to an impressive Hall of Fame career.

I may be in the minority here, but I actually wasn't too excited to hear Jason Witten was going to end his retirement and rejoin the Dallas Cowboys. I thought he retired at the right time last year, going out on his terms instead of letting father time force him out. He definitely didn't have anything else to prove on the field, but sometimes hunger gets the best of us all.

That's what Jason Witten is. He's hungry! He's not stupid. He's looked this Dallas Cowboys roster over and sees just how talented it is from top to bottom. He knows this team has a real shot at reaching the promised land this year, adding yet another Super Bowl trophy to their collection. He wanted in, and rightfully so.

Witten may not have a full tank of gas anymore, but he's got enough left to help get this team to their desired destination. Despite my hesitation at first, I'm really excited to have him back in uniform. I'm really looking forward to seeing him back in action now, but more importantly having him on hand to mentor these younger players around him.

Most importantly though, I'm really hoping the 2019 season can be the storybook ending he deserves. He's been such an important ambassador to the NFL throughout his career, both on and off the field. What better way to end such a decorated career than with a little jewelry to put on his finger?

Dak Prescott, Jason Witten

Dallas Cowboys TE Jason Witten

The 11 time Pro Bowler still holds a lot of records in the NFL and with the Dallas Cowboys, despite not playing last season. I'll let you look those up for yourself if you want, but the impact he has had on the game throughout his career is undeniable, and should continue to be so. The Cowboys or Witten wouldn't have reunited if either thought that wasn't the case anymore.

I know many of you may be thinking I'm probably reaching little to suggest this 2019 Dallas Cowboys team has a chance at going all the way this year, but I don't think so. This is a team with Super Bowl aspirations and the roster to do it.

The Cowboys already had a championship caliber defense last season and they're even better now after making a few upgrades. This alone will make them a much more dangerous team this year, but they're not slouches on the offensive side of the ball either.

The offense was good last season after making the Amari Cooper trade, but should be able to take the next step this year. They only lost Cole Beasley, but replaced him with Randall Cobb, who has a chance to be even better if he can stay healthy. Then if you throw in the addition of Jason Witten and the development of a few players, this is looking more and more like one of the more dangerous offenses in the NFL.

Maybe, just maybe, this is the team that can finally get the Dallas Cowboys back to the Super Bowl and help Jason Witten end his Hall of Fame career in a storybook like manner. Hello Hollywood! You've got a blockbuster movie in the making.

Do you think Jason Witten can end his career in a storybook like manner?



Continue Reading

Star Blog

Travis Frederick’s Return Named Cowboys Biggest Reason For Excitement

Kevin Brady

Published

on

Dallas Cowboys 2019 Offseason Preview: Center

Overall, Cowboys Nation feels to be in a positive mood during this year's offseason. Despite early angst over lack of action at the start of free agency, and concern over the Cowboys' draft strategy, most within the fan base seem to have high, yet realistic, hopes for the 2019 season.

Most seem to believe the NFC East will be a two team race, with the last two champions battling for the crown once again down the stretch of the season. Others can see the potential for a dark-horse candidate in Washington, but still believe the Cowboys roster has the edge.

So while Cowboys fans may not think they need a singular reason to look forward to the Fall of 2019, Bleacher Report's Brent Sobleski gave them one this week.

Every NFL Team's Biggest Reason to Look Forward to 2019 Season

NFL Brent Sobleski @@brentsobleski Twitter Logo NFL Analyst The offseason can be as thrilling for NFL fans as the regular season. Player movement constantly refreshes rosters-whether through free agency, the draft or trades. Significant changes inject excitement into franchises, personnel and fanbases. A one-time league doormat can become the league's "it' team simply through a string of acquisitions.

Brent identified the biggest reason for each team to look forward to 2019, with the return of center Travis Frederick being the Cowboys' submission. There's no question that when healthy, Frederick is one of the best centers in the game, and anchors an offensive line many still consider to be at the top of the league.

"A full year with wide receiver Amari Cooper and re-signing Demarcus Lawrence to a long-term deal are both reasons for the Dallas Cowboys to be excited. However, the return of Travis Frederick to man the middle of the offensive line is far more pertinent."

Frederick missed all of the 2018 season after being diagnosed with Guillain-Barre syndrome, a rare disease that I am not nearly qualified enough to discuss. What I do know is that it can be very serious, and it kept Frederick out for the entire year.

The Cowboys offensive line suffered during the early part of 2018, largely due in part to Travis Frederick's absence. Yes, Joe Looney filled in and played as well as anyone could have hoped for, but the disconnect in communication across the offensive line was clear without their usual center. Especially during the first couple months of the season.

If Frederick is fully back and healthy, his presence alone will take the Cowboys offensive line back towards their peak. Combine his comeback with a healthy Zack Martin, and a now bulked up Connor Williams, and the interior of this line has the chance to be special.



Continue Reading



Enjoy 40% commissions on officially licensed products as a FanPrint affiliate. You can even make your own, fully licensed Cowboys and player designs! Get started here

Trending