It is one of the burning questions for the Dallas Cowboys this off season, and yet it appears they are no closer to an answer than they were at the very end of the miserable 2015 season. Will defensive end Greg Hardy be with this team in 2016?
I'll give my take on the matter later on, but let's begin by simply laying out the facts. Hardy played just 1 game in 2014, making his last full season 2013 when he was with the Carolina Panthers. That year, he recorded 15 sacks and was tied for the league lead in tackles.
In 12 games as a Cowboy in 2015 (four missed due to suspension), Hardy totaled just six sacks - but was consistently around the quarterback. Even when he wasn't disrupting a play, at the very least Hardy always drew respect from opposing offensive lines - freeing up the likes of DeMarcus Lawrence to get around the other edge.
We know Rod Marinelli loves versatility from every member of his defense, and the 27 year old Hardy certainly gave this unit just that with his ability to rush from the edge or on the inside.
So, in pure football analysis, Greg Hardy is a guy the Cowboys want back in 2016. This is especially true when you look at the depth at the defensive end position. Only one player on the depth chart who has recorded a career sack (Lawrence) is under contract for next season.
Jeremy Mincey is a free agent for Dallas, and in his contract year he failed to record a single sack. While the progression of D-Law at the end of 2015 was a very encouraging sign for fans, investing the bulk of the pass-rush next season to him and Randy Gregory is a risky move for a team that is in win-now mode.
Winning teams need veterans along the defensive line, and Greg Hardy is certainly that.
What we also know is that the Cowboys had anything but a good time controlling the headlines swirling around Greg Hardy this season. While a large amount of them may have been unwarranted, Jerry Jones and the Cowboys understand what they are - and the special attention that goes into their brand.
While we never got a full picture from Jason Garrett, he did reference throughout the season multiple occasions in which he had to talk to Hardy behind closed doors. Garrett is often unfairly criticized based on what he makes public by the fans, but behind closed doors he runs a tight ship that carries a ton of public respect from his players.
While it may be fair to assume that some of these closed-door meetings with Hardy were over marginal things, the frequency of them based on what we know is concerning.
However, Cowboys fans would still like to see Hardy back with the team next year.
Do you want Greg Hardy back?
My question to the 46% of voters that said no would be this: Did you vote that way because you legitimately do not want to see Greg Hardy in Dallas next season, or simply out of frustration that the team has not made anything clear in regards to his status?
While Joey Bosa, Noah Spence and even Ronald Blair may all be enticing options in the draft to replace Hardy, the team would also be admitting to a major fault if moving on from the Hardy experiment after just one season.
They took their lumps for it in 2015, along with all of the other fanfare that comes from a 4-12 football team that entered the season with a Super Bowl in mind. Now in 2016, if they feel Hardy has truthfully learned from his mistakes, they can take full advantage of the signing - boosting a pass rush that could lead a much improved defense.
I would like to see Hardy with the team next season, but obviously have no say in the matter. The people who do have also not told us much, and the longer this drags on the more the speculation will grow.
If you voted in the above poll, feel free to expand on your choice here with a comment below or on Twitter @ShoreSportsNJ!
Is it Too Late For Dallas to Fire OC Scott Linehan?
Grab your pitchforks and your torches, it's time to run the Dallas Cowboys Offensive Coordinator Scott Linehan out of town. His playcalling has been absolutely atrocious season and it's time for him to hit the road, even if there are only two regular-season games left on the schedule.
It's completely unorthodox for an NFL team to fire an offensive coordinator this late in the season, but just last week we saw the Minnesota Vikings do just that when they parted ways with John DeFilippo. It was definitely a bold move to make considering the Vikings are still in playoff contention, but it was something they believed was in the best interest of their team.
I believe if the Dallas Cowboys want to do what's best for their team right now and not later, then they should go ahead and cut ties with Scott Linehan. His predictability and un-creativeness as a play caller is holding back a talented offense, which is hurting the overall team as a result. He's been given every opportunity to turn things around, but enough is enough.
I'd personally be on board with Jason Garrett taking over the playcalling duties. He has the experience and held the position with the Cowboys from 2007 until Linehan was hired. I'd even consider giving Kellen Moore a shot as the OC. He knows the system and has worked closely with Quarterback Dak Prescott. Regardless, the Cowboys need to find some way to increase their offensive productivity.
Right now the Cowboys offense is the 26th scoring offense in the NFL and are averaging just 19.7 points per game. To make matters worse they are the 31st ranked Red Zone offense in the league. I don't know about you, but I think that is completely unacceptable with the talent they have on the offensive side of the ball.
Firing Linehan has been a long time coming. The Cowboys flirted with the idea earlier this season during the bye week and should've pulled the trigger then, but for some reason or another decided to let him stick around. They are definitely still paying for that mistake now.
The Cowboys mistake not to replace Linehan could mean yet another early exit in the playoffs, something we have unfortunately become accustomed to. Scoring just 19 points a game isn't going to get them very far, which is truly unfortunate considering the talent they've acquired this season.
Unfortunately, as much as we would love to see Scott Linehan tarred and feathered and run out of town, I just don't see the Cowboys doing that before their season is officially over. But, in no way should he be allowed to retain his position beyond this season. He clearly isn't the answer any longer.
Do you think the Dallas Cowboys should fire Scott Linehan?
Despite Embarrassing Showing, Health Remains Biggest Cowboys Concern
What is it about the AFC South with these Dallas Cowboys?
Dallas' five game winning streak came to a close on Sunday, as they got straight-up embarrassed by the now 8-6 Indianapolis Colts on the road. The loss was the first since the Cowboys were embarrassed by a different AFC South competitor, the Tennessee Titans, on Monday night football earlier this season.
Though the final was 23-0, and not a single phase (or really even a single player) showed much fight or promise, the biggest concern I have for the Cowboys moving forward didn't change because of the putrid performance. It didn't change because the defense was gashed play after play or the offense failed to finish a single drive. And it didn't even change because both the Redskins and Eagles secured season-saving victories on the same day Dallas was dismantled.
The biggest concern is still their health, particularly across the offensive line.
That was not a playoff caliber interior offensive line the Cowboys put out their on Sunday. Not even close.
With their backup center in Joe Looney, backup guard in Connor Williams, and the very last interior offensive linemen on their roster in Adam Redmond playing for basically the entire game, this offense never had a chance. Dak Prescott wasn't any more inaccurate or indecisive than normal, but all those who like to scream "step up in the pocket" whenever he is sacked did not seem to have an argument this week.
There often was no pocket to step into, as those interior three, specifically Looney and Redmond, failed to provide much protection or confidence for Prescott at all. Joe Looney has actually been rather solid this season, but Sunday felt like one of his worst games of the entire year.
The Cowboys absolutely need Zack Martin to get healthy if they are to make any noise whatsoever in the postseason. At the very least, the need Xavier Su'a-Filo to come back and replace Redmond, and regain the form he displayed during his debut against the Eagles back in November.
Prescott already has issues with his pocket presence and footwork when pressured, so throwing three backup-level linemen right in front of him is not a recipe for success for the Cowboys.
I'm not jumping out of the window over this loss, and I don't think any of you should be either. Dallas had won three straight incredibly emotional and important home games to extend, save, and solidify their season respectively before this loss. They had also just about clinched the NFC East a week ago with their win over Philadelphia, and they played like a team that was due a flat performance
A letdown loss on the road, against a good team I might add, is not the end of the world. The bigger issue here is their health, because if Martin can return to anchor this offensive line, the offense should look a whole lot better than they did against Indianapolis.
It's time to move on from Sunday, go beat Tampa Bay, officially clinch the division, and get ready for Wild Card Weekend.
Where In The World Is DE Taco Charlton?
Over pretty much the last decade, the Dallas Cowboys have been rock solid with their first round picks. With selections of Ezekiel Elliott, Travis Frederick, Byron Jones, Tyron Smith, Zack Martin, and Leighton Vander Esch (just to name a handful), Dallas has rebuilt the core of their roster through the NFL Draft.
It's nearly impossible to bat .1000 in any round of the draft, however, and this appears to be the current case with the Cowboys' 2017 first round pick.
Defensive end Taco Charlton has not had the sophomore season that he, or anyone, had hoped for. A healthy scratch last Sunday, Charlton has only been active for 1 of the Cowboys' last 5 games, and has not recorded a sack or tackle since week 9.
Prior to disappearing with injuries and "attitude issues," Charlton had only recorded 1 sack on the season and was beginning to fall behind his Hot Boy-brethren. Defensive end Randy Gregory has reached his form over the last few weeks, Tyrone Crawford is having arguably a career year, and DeMarcus Lawrence is one of the best ends in all of football.
This doesn't leave much room for Charlton, who's now having issues even getting on the gameday roster. Rod Marinelli dodged questions about Taco Charlton earlier this week, vaguely saying they are "moving forward" and that he'd like to talk about other players on his defensive line who are performing.
Rod Marinelli on Taco Charlton's benching and being inactive last week: "We just keep moving along keep going forward. It's kinda been out there I'd leave it at that. I'd rather talk about our two tackles.
Charlton has not been quiet about his displeasure as of late, either. He's taken to Twitter to voice his frustrations, saying that not only is his shoulder fine but that the Dallas media is making up stories about his absence. He's also posted some cryptic tweets such as this one, with a picture of Allen Iverson and a caption reading "Every players needs that one coach to believe in them."
Maybe Taco is right. Maybe he just needs increased opportunity and a support system/coach that believes in him whole-heartedly. After all, Charlton has faced nothing but doubters and detractors since the second he was drafted by the Dallas Cowboys.
But in the NFL, the ultimate "what have you done for me lately" sport, it's hard to imagine he'll get that unwavering support anywhere in the league. He's going to have to "earn" his playing time, as head coach Jason Garrett spoke to earlier in the week. But with the plethora of talent the Cowboys are already putting out there on the defensive line, it's becoming difficult to see exactly where Taco Charlton can fit in on this defense.
It's possible, and fine, if it is simply not a fit between Charlton and the Cowboys at this point. But I'd also be wary of giving up on your first round pick in just his second NFL season. Another offseason with the team, working on his craft and getting fully healthy, should do Charlton wonders, and hopefully allow us to get a better read on his future with the Cowboys going forward.
Until then, we are all left to scratch out heads and wonder what in the world is going on with the Cowboys and Taco Charlton, and if the former first round pick will have a future in Dallas at all.
Star Blog2 weeks ago
Why is Jerry Jones “keeping a very close eye” on the Kareem Hunt Case?
Dallas Cowboys2 weeks ago
David Irving’s Return Could Make Cowboys’ Defense Even Scarier
Dallas Cowboys2 weeks ago
Wide Receiver Michael Gallup Making a Huge Impact for Dallas Cowboys
Dallas Cowboys6 days ago
Tavon Austin’s Return Should Make Cowboys Offense More Dangerous
Star Blog7 days ago
Time to see What Darius Jackson can do as Zeke’s Backup?
Dallas Cowboys2 weeks ago
2018 Rushing Title: Ezekiel Elliott, Todd Gurley in Neck-and-Neck Race
Game Notes2 weeks ago
Amari Cooper, Ezekiel Elliott Key to Clipping the Eagles Wings?
Dallas Cowboys1 day ago
Cowboys Nation, It’s Time To Take a Deep Breath