Is The Cowboys Secondary Suddenly A Cause For Concern? ⋆
Connect with us

Is The Cowboys Secondary Suddenly A Cause For Concern?

Is The Cowboys Secondary Suddenly A Cause Of Concern?

Star Blog

Is The Cowboys Secondary Suddenly A Cause For Concern?

Is The Cowboys Secondary Suddenly A Cause For Concern?

Yesterday we learned the fates of the Dallas Cowboys free agent cornerbacks Brandon Carr and Morris Claiborne. Carr will be suiting up for the Baltimore Ravens next season and Claiborne will be playing for the New York Jets. With their departure, they join Barry Church and J.J. Wilcox as secondary players the Cowboys have lost via free agency. Suddenly things are starting to look a little sparse on the back end of the Cowboys defense, which has become a concern for a lot of fans.

There were many of us fans that believed the Dallas Cowboys would try to retain either Brandon Carr or Morris Claiborne, but it looks as if they were willing to move on and try to rebuild the secondary without them. So, if you’re counting that is a total of four secondary players that started on defense at some point in 2016, without a lot of additions to take over. It’s no wonder Cowboys fans feel a little left in the dark.

I for one am not panicking, because I think I see the bigger picture of what the Cowboys are trying to accomplish this off-season. I mean, how many of you have been wanting the organization to upgrade from Brandon Carr, Morris Claiborne, Barry Church, and J.J. Wilcox these past few seasons? Now that it they are all moving on, everyone starts to freak out.

Trust me on this and take a deep breath. The Cowboys know what they’re doing, so we are just going to have to trust the process and let everything play out. Let me try to break this down a little bit better for you, so that I can hopefully ease your mind.

Cowboys Secondary: Cornerbacks

CB Anthony BrownIf you are keeping track, and I’m sure you are, then you have come to the realization that the Dallas Cowboys have only added Nolan Carroll, but lost both Brandon Carr and Morris Claiborne in free agency. Things don’t quite add up do they?

Carroll was brought in to more than likely take over for Carr. They are both basically the same size, but I think Carroll is probably better of the two players, although it may be a slight margin of victory. No doubt he will start at one of the outside cornerback spots, the other probably to be played by the second year CB Anthony Brown.

Brown had a fantastic rookie season and his addition to the Cowboys roster last year couldn’t have come at a better time. He ended up starting nine games as a rookie and is now the future for the organization.

That leaves Orlando Scandrick and he will probably move back into the nickel, where he is at his best. Scandrick took some time to get healthy last year, but was playing really well towards the end of the season.

With Carroll, Brown, and Scandrick the Cowboys already have a solid group of starting CBs. But, you can bet they aren’t done addressing the position just yet. I will guarantee you that they will add another talented cornerback in the upcoming draft with one of their first few draft picks. That will solidify the CB position and build the foundation for years to come.

Cowboys Secondary: Safeties

S Jeff HeathLike the cornerback position, the Dallas Cowboys have lost two of their safeties, Barry Church and J.J. Wilcox. Unfortunately, they haven’t made any new additions, which either means they think they have their starter currently on the roster or they’re still mulling over the free agent options. Of course, they could draft another safety, which isn’t entirely out of the question.

In all honesty, I wouldn’t mind seeing Jeff Heath receive more playing time starting next to Byron Jones on the back end of the Cowboys defense. He seems to always be around the ball making plays and creating turnovers, which is something the defense can certainly use.

There are several free agent options still available that can step in and be a day one starter. Of course, that would involve spending money and I’m not quite sure if anybody they signed would be better than what they currently have or what they could possibly add through the draft.

The 2017 safety draft class is deep and there are quite a few players in the first few rounds that could come in and not only solidify the back end the defense, but be an upgrade over what the Cowboys let walk this off-season. Honestly, I think this is the route that they prefer to go.


As you can see, things aren’t quite as bad as they seem right now. The Dallas Cowboys have a plan in place, we as fans just have to trust the process because unfortunately we really don’t have any other choice.

Personally, I don’t know if they will make any more moves to address the secondary before the 2017 NFL Draft. I think they will probably draft both a cornerback and safety in the first two rounds and move on from there. Fortunately, both the cornerback and safety positions are pretty deep this year, so they should be able to come away with a starter at both positions.

Does any of this help ease your concerns about the Dallas Cowboys secondary?

Brian Martin

Level C2/C3 quadriplegic. College graduate with a bachelors degree in sports and health sciences-concentration sports management. Sports enthusiast. Dallas Cowboys fanatic. Lover of life with a glass half-full point of view.

  • leo thomas

    I like what they are doing it had to be done sooner than later. This CB group seem to be very big, strong and fast. Tapper now has his chance to show his pass rushing skills.

    • Brian Martin

      I agree Leo. It was time to make a change to the secondary. I think it’s a shock to most people because it’s kind of all at once.

  • Terence Rendon

    Now let get for real Mr. Martin. Signing Carroll is a down grade over the player of Carr and Claiborne. If Carroll was a better player Philly would never let him go in the first places. Carroll could not hold the line. If you go by all the people who does ranking players by there stats over last year {2016) you see both Claiborne (19) and Carr was in the 20’s best CB in the league last year. Were Carroll was rank 55th best CB, Now for Brown, and Scandrick . Brown is up and coming and will be a good CB when he get more season under the belt. Sccandrick is getting older and starting to show all the injury that his body has taken. Now for the Safeties. J.J. Wilcox has never started a games in NFL. He not that good of a player and don’t have the truth confident of the coaching staff that he can get the job done. Byron Jones can not do everything by himself. Yes it has to be done at some point down the road but not all at one time. Now for tapper on being a every down player I don’t see it. Now you have 1 DE is out for the season for off the field issues that got him into trouble with NFL. Then you have another out for 4 to 6 games for the same reason. Dallas is so cap strap it not even funny any more. They need to learn now to manage there money better. They need to stop given out big money contract to. They need to look how the rest of the league is doing it.

    • Terence Rendon

      I also put in over 2500 hours in draft and free agency players every year. I know my stuff. You use draft to build a team of the future. But you use free agency to fill in the holes. Not the other way around

      • Brian Martin

        I think that’s exactly what the Cowboys are doing.

    • Brian Martin

      I disagree with you about Carroll. He is just as good as Carr, if not a little bit better. I think you’ll be a good fit in the Cowboys secondary. Scandrick didn’t start the year healthy, but he got better as the season progressed. I really don’t think the Cowboys secondary is any worse than it was in 2016 right now. In fact, I think they will be better next season after we see who they add through the draft.

    • Troy Wecker

      Carr was never the player he was advertised to be. OBJ made him look absolutely stupid on national television 2 years ago. His only saving grace…he never missed a game. Mo never lived up to his first round draft status. Every year he was plagued by one injury or another that kept him sidelined. Personally, I like Wilcox. He was a hard hitter, the enforcer of the group. He laid out OBJ in the season opener of 2015-that was a thing of beauty. However, he frequently took bad angles missing big plays. I agree that Dallas is cap strapped and for that reason you “can’t put a steak on every plate.” They should look very closely at the way the Patriots do business and copy that. Six Superbowls in 17 years is something that should make you stand up and take notice.

Reader Survey

Want to help make Inside The Star better?

We’re collecting feedback from our readers about the site. It only takes <2 minutes to complete, and can be done from any device.

> Take the survey now

Don’t worry, your information will not be shared with anyone but me (Bryson T.).

Cowboys News Feed App for Android

Popular Now


From Our Partners

Enjoy 40% commissions on officially licensed products as a FanPrint affiliate. You can even make your own, fully licensed Cowboys and player designs! Get started here
To Top