In reply to Tom Knapp.

Tom LoPinto Romo was a much superior QB, he just wasn't dragged through 2 postseasons like Eli was. Eli never beat a single playoff team that scored more than 20 points and he still barely won 5/8 games.

The comparisons don't stop there.

300+ yard games:
Eli: 51
Romo: 46 (-5)

3+ TD games
Eli: 49
Romo: 40 (-9)

100+ Passer Rating Games:
Eli: 64
Romo: 68 (+4)

Now might be a good time to point out something else about them....

Regular season games:
Eli: 234 (117-117 record)
Romo: 127 (78-49 record) (-107 games played)

Romo pretty much kept pace with Eli while playing in 107 fewer games. I don't understand how anyone remotely thinks that Eli was a great QB. Even if it was 100% him in both playoffs, which it nearly 100% was not, that does not justify his below average career.

Eli only has his high career totals because he played 16 years. Even below average years will add up if given enough time. His TD percentage and yards/attempt are not even in the top 70 all time.