Connect with us

Dallas Cowboys

Ranking the Top 10 Quarterbacks in Dallas Cowboys History

Jess Haynie

Published

on

Troy Aikman, Tony Romo
AP Photo/James D Smith

With Tony Romo's retirement and release from the Dallas Cowboys this week, it seems a good time to look at where he stands among the all-time quarterbacks in franchise history. Based on a variety of factors, I've put together my Top-10 list for the greatest passers to ever wear The Star.

Of course, lists like these are always subjective and based on one individual's values and priorities. After reading, I hope that you will comment with your reaction and your own lists.

(All of the statistics used in this article came from Pro Football Reference.)

1 of 10
Use ← → keys to browse

10. Jason Garrett (1993-1999)

Jason Garrett, Packers

Jason Garrett

It would be easy to dismiss Garrett, a career backup, as an all-time great. However, a closer look at Jason's numbers with the Cowboys make him stand out.

During his seven years as a backup, Jason Garrett went 6-3 in games that he started in relief of Troy Aikman. That .667 winning percentage puts him near the top of all Cowboys starters. His passer rating of 83.2 is slightly above Aikman (81.6) and just below Roger Staubach (8.4).

Elevating Garrett over the rest of the pack is a single day (pictured above) that stands out in Cowboys history. As a third stringer in 1994, Garrett had to start in the Thanksgiving game against Green Bay due to injuries to both Aikman and Rodney Peete. Jason threw for 311 yards and two touchdowns as the Cowboys stunned Brett Favre and the Packers for a 42-31 victory.

Jason Garrett was the consummate backup. He only threw five interceptions in 294 attempts, which gives him the lowest INT ratio of anyone on our list but Dak Prescott. The Cowboys' dynasty train was able to keep rolling whenever Garrett was called upon.

1 of 10
Use ← → keys to browse


Cowboys fan since 1992, blogger since 2011. Bringing you the objectivity of an outside perspective with the passion of a die-hard fan. I love to talk to my readers, so please comment on any article and I'll be sure to respond!

Advertisement
7 Comments
  • Russ_Te

    And Staubach’s comeback wins are legendary – only a Google search away. He could strap the team on his back and will a win, whereas Aikman was IMO the ultimate system QB.

    Aikman had to have talent around him – in 1996 with Irvin suspended and Emmitt Smith hurt, that became clear. But with it, he was a machine.

    The classic 1974 Thanksgiving comeback of rookie QB Clint Longley, as told by the immortal John Facenda

    ;^)

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcteaJHZDF0

    • Jess Haynie

      While I get where you’re coming from, I think Aikman was essentially the offensive coordinator in 1995 and his leadership was essential in keeping guys in check during the dynasty. So much of what makes a great QB goes in in the huddle, locker room, and practice field and anyone from that era will tell how important Aikman’s presence was.

      • Russ_Te

        No doubt Aikman was a general on the team, and it was a factor. He meshed well with Jimmy Johnson’s hard-ass approach, and was at odds with Switzer’s more relaxed coaching.

        I’ve often said the similarity between Johnson and Landry was an intolerance for mediocrity, and that was Aikman also. I hope that Dak will go in that direction also as he completely assumes the mantle now. The difference between W and L, even titles, can be 1 play & who wants to make it most.

  • wconsult

    This is a great list and very accurate. I hope that Dak will be able to overtake Romo at some point in his career. Overtaking the top two will mean he had a INCREDIBLE career with the “BOYS”

    • Jess Haynie

      Thanks! Here’s a fun question; if/when Dak wins his first Super Bowl, does he automatically jump to #3 on the list?

      • John Williams

        I don’t think so. While playoff success is important, it’s also a team statistic. I’d need to see Dak have several years of playing success along with that championship.

  • John Williams

    Can’t find anything to argue with on this list.

    Dak has more to prove in order to climb higher. While Tony Romo’s numbers are all-time leading, that playoff success has to be considered, especially in context of Cowboys history. Hard to put a guy higher than 3 when he didn’t play in an NFC Championship game.

    The Danny White-Tony Romo comparison is just too accurate.

Player News

Oakland Raiders’ Wide Receiver Amari Cooper On the Trade Block

John Williams

Published

on

Oakland Raiders' Wide Receiver Amari Cooper On the Trade Block

Aside from Wide Receiver Cole Beasley, the Dallas Cowboys haven't received much production from their wide receiver group outside of the occasional big play from fellow wide outs Michael Gallup or Tavon Austin. Well, the Oakland Raiders apparently are willing to listen to offers for Wide Receiver Amari Cooper and, according to Michael Rapaport, are asking for a first round draft pick in return.

Allan Bell on Twitter

Raiders want a first round pick for Amari Cooper, per @RapSheet.

 

The Dallas Cowboys could use someone with Cooper's ability, even if he has been a drop machine through his first four seasons. In his first two seasons in the NFL, 2015 and 2016, Cooper averaged 77 receptions on 131 targets, for 1,111.5 yards, and 5.5 touchdowns. Through his first three seasons in the NFL, Cooper averaged 11 drops a season, including 18 in his rookie season.

Any time you start a discussion about whether you should trade for someone, the question always begins with "what are you paying?" What would you be willing to pay for Amari Cooper? After back-to-back 1,000 yard seasons to start his career, he only went for 680 yards in 14 games (48.6 yards per game). Though the yardage wasn't great last year, he did catch seven touchdowns for the Oakland Raiders.

So far in 2018, Cooper is averaging 46.7 yards per game on 3.67 receptions per game and has only scored one touchdown.

I wouldn't send a top 60 pick for Amari Cooper. He's a good player, but is he better than what Michael Gallup could be? Because if you trade for Cooper he's going to likely eat into Gallup's snap count and we need to find out if Michal Gallup is a player that the Dallas Cowboys could rely on in the future. But, if the Cowboys coaching staff brought Cooper in to replace Allen Hurns, then I'd be very happy to talk about acquiring the former first round draft choice.

A starting wide receiver group of Cole Beasley, Amari Cooper, and Michael Gallup would be a very difficult group to cover and Quarterback Dak Prescott showed on Sunday that he has what it takes to get the ball down field to his receivers.

The Cowboys probably wouldn't make this trade, unless Jerry Jones got involved, because they value their draft picks too much, but if the Dallas Cowboys could get him for a third round pick I'd do it in a heart beat. For a second round pick, I'd have to get a fifth or sixth back from Oakland in that deal. Cooper's a good player, but hasn't shown to be one of the best at his position.

There are a couple other players from Oakland that I'm more interested in trading for.

✭ ✭ ✭ ✭ ✭

What do you think? Would you trade for Amari Cooper, and if so, what would you be willing to give?

 


Continue Reading

Game Notes

Sean’s Scout: Cowboys Win Big On the Ground, In Trenches With Rout of Jaguars

Sean Martin

Published

on

Sean's Scout: Cowboys Win Big On the Ground, In Trenches With Rout of Jaguars

On paper, the Dallas Cowboys were going to struggle generating any offense against the Jacksonville Jaguars on Sunday. The league's top defense matched up against a Cowboys team that came in ranked 30th in pass yards per game, with the defensive front to slow down Ezekiel Elliott, the Cowboys seemed destined for a 2-4 start through the end of six weeks.

Thankfully, NFL games are not played on paper, and the action on the field at AT&T Stadium would tell an entirely different -- albeit unforeseen -- story of the Cowboys dominance. With a season high 206 rushing yards, the Cowboys ran wild on the Jaguars, making this win look remarkably easy behind a defense up to the task of defending the lead from the opening drive.

The Cowboys improved their home record to 3-0 this season. Now coming off their most impressive effort of 2018, the team earned a shot at first place as they travel to the Washington Redskins in week seven - searching for their first road win of the season.

Here are my initial thoughts on the Cowboys drubbing of the Jaguars, a wonderfully unexpected result that keeps plenty of postseason dreams alive for Dallas.

  • Jerry Jones caught a lot of heat this week for his comments on Head Coach Jason Garrett's job security, but certainly deserves a lot of credit for wanting to see more of Quarterback Dak Prescott as a runner.

Jones called Garrett the "real deal", a sentiment better reserved for Prescott when he's able to take matters into his own hands and run the football. With 82 yards on the ground, Dak was eight yards shy of doubling his previous career high, sprinting down the sideline for the Cowboys first touchdown of the game.

Prescott's rushing ability takes advantage of the Cowboys offensive line's ability to get out in space and block. A fearless runner that can keep defenses honest on his own before unleashing Elliott on the ground, Prescott's legs are the key to the Cowboys repeating a performance like this later in the season.

  • Without Leonard Fournette, the Jaguars are not built to play from behind, and the Cowboys defensive line made sure of this.

The "Hot Boyz" were at full strength with David Irving back on the field for the first time this season. Rushing with DeMarcus Lawrence, Maliek Collins, and Randy Gregory on the Jaguars' third down attempt following Brett Maher's first FG, Irving was able to chase after Bortles and force an incomplete pass out of bounds as he recorded the QB hit.

With Jaylon Smith also blitzing on the play, this had to be an incredibly proud moment for Garrett, Rod Marinelli, and the Jones' upstairs, as their trust in both Irving and Gregory paid off to create a fearsome pass rush.

Knowing they had interior defenders that could get off blocks and finish plays, the Cowboys defensive ends in this game were aggressive rushing up the field and collapsing the pocket on Bortles.

  • Michael Gallup is slowly emerging as this team's number one wide receiver, thanks to his ability to make plays on contested balls. 

Look no further than Allen Hurns' stat line from this win to see why rookie Wide Receiver Michael Gallup is going to be crucial to the Cowboys passing offense as this season progresses. Hurns was the only receiver targeted that failed to bring in a catch, as Prescott has struggled to find any rhythm with the big-bodied free agent signing.

On the other side of the field, Gallup has flashed similar 'above the rim' abilities to Hurns, while also being a more reliable route runner with big play potential after the catch. Cole Beasley was open all afternoon against the Jaguars secondary, but early in the game when Prescott needed a play he was able to fit some great passes into Gallup.

I include Gallup's touchdown catch that was called back, since it was a safe strike from Dak. Putting the ball where only Gallup could make the incredible catch, Gallup was inches away from scoring his first NFL touchdown.

Instead, with the Cowboys rotation at WR trimmed down due to injury, Gallup staked his claim for a larger share of the snaps in the Cowboys 40-point performance.

  • This was another good game for rookie Left Guard Connor Williams, but I thought he had a chance to prevent the Calais Campbell sack that forced the Cowboys to settle for three points on their first possession. 

As Prescott stepped up in the pocket, Campbell was able to change directions and cut across the face of Williams. With nobody else in front of him, it looked like Williams was in prime position to deliver a shot to Campbell, but was unable to get a hand on the Jaguars top pass rusher.

Reacting late to the whole play, Campbell finished the play for his only sack, a stat the Cowboys will certainly take when evaluating a fairly dominant day for their entire offensive line.

  • The rate at which Linebackers Jaylon Smith and rookie Leighton Vander Esch are making open field tackles is easily the best thing going for the Cowboys defense right now.

Whenever Jaylon Smith appears in the vicinity of an opposing receiver or running back, they better brace for impact. Where Smith has been the enforcer of the Cowboys defense at MIKE, Vander Esch is playing off him perfectly as the second starter with range and athleticism to cover from sideline to sideline.

The Cowboys have allowed an average of 16.67 points over their last three games without Sean Lee, a full point better than the three games Lee's played against the Panthers, Giants, and Seahawks. This is exactly the reason why Dallas was so comfortable drafting Vander Esch.

Even still, having the Boise State product rising to the occasion so early in his Cowboys career alongside Smith gives the Cowboys a LB pairing they can trust for years to come. This is more than they ever signed up for when drafting both players to ideally play with Lee, something they'll still get the chance to do in the coming weeks.

✭ ✭ ✭ ✭ ✭

Alternating wins and losses through their first six games, the 2018 Cowboys remain an enigma that (again, on paper) have a lot to build on after defeating the Jaguars soundly. The ease at which the Cowboys moved the ball should at least partially be attributed to how difficult it was for the Cowboys to manage any offense in their three road losses.

With a defense that's shows up each week to keep Dallas in any game, the time is now for the offense to travel away from AT&T Stadium and earn the Cowboys first winning streak at Washington. In doing so, the Cowboys would claim first place in the NFC East.

Given the expectations set on this team before the year, this feels like the only surefire way for the Cowboys to put their tumultuous start behind them, serving as a reminder that the NFL is the ultimate week-to-week league.

Keeping that in mind, this team deserves a day to enjoy their decisive win from Sunday. Welcome back to Victory Monday, Cowboys Nation.

Tell us what you think about "Sean’s Scout: Cowboys Win Big On the Ground, In Trenches With Rout of Jaguars" in the comments below. You can also email me at Sean.Martin@InsideTheStar.com, or Tweet to me at @SeanMartinNFL!


Continue Reading

Game Notes

Dallas Cowboys Beat Jacksonville Jaguars 40-7: Who are the 3 Stars?

John Williams

Published

on

Dallas Cowboys Beat Jacksonville Jaguars 40-7: Who are the 3 Stars?

What a way to bounce back after a disappointing loss on the road in week five against the Houston Texans. As frustrating as that outcome was against the Texans, this victory was equally as sweet, as the Dallas Cowboys bounced back with a dominating 40-7 win over the Jacksonville Jaguars.

That was a much needed win for a team that hopes to be contending for the NFC East title in 2018. And you better believe that at 3-3 on the season, they are still in the thick of that divisional race.

There were a few stand out performances in the blowout victory, but to make this a more difficult exercise for myself, I'm not including any honorable mentions. That's just cheating.

Make sure to let us know who your 3 Stars are in the comment section.

First ✭

Dak Prescott

If there was ever a time and ever a moment in which Dak Prescott needed to have a career defining performance, this was the week that he needed to do that.

The virtual boo birds were out in full force this week following another poor performance for the Dallas Cowboys quarterback in the last 13 games. Prescott responded in a huge way with big time throws on third downs and looking extremely poised and confident.

The final passing line isn't all that extraordinary as he went 17/27 for 183 yards, two passing touchdowns, and a passer rating of 107.5, per NFL.com. Sure, if you just look at passing stats, you can argue it's not that impressive, but when you include his rushing numbers in the discussion, even the staunchest realist or Dak-hater has to admit that Dak Prescott had a great day on Sunday.

Dak Prescott set career highs in carries (11) and rushing yards (82) while adding a touchdown on the ground. It was his first rushing touchdown since week 15 of 2017. For a quarterback to end up only 18 yards shy of a hundred yards rushing is huge for your offense.

They weren't all designed runs either.

Dak Prescott in games past tried to force passes when running lanes were available to him on the outside. On Sunday against the Jaguars, he took his opportunities to run the ball when he was flushed from the pocket and the Jaguars paid dearly.

He looked like the Dak Prescott that took the NFL by storm his rookie season and for eight games in the 2017 season. He was poised in the pocket, confident in his arm and his receivers, and was seeing the field better than he had in the previous 13 games.

All against one of the best defenses in the NFL.

Second ✭

Cole Beasley

The Dallas Cowboys needed a big game from a wide receiver in a bad way and Cole Beasley stepped up. After a week of being asked questions about the play and production of the Dallas Cowboys wide receiver group Beasley had answers all day on Sunday against a variety of coverages and players when Jacksonville went man-to-man.

After posting nine catches for 101 yards and both of Dak Prescott's two passing touchdowns, Beasley silenced the "wide receivers are the problem" critics with a performance reminiscent of his 2016 career year.

Cole Beasley was getting open at will against man coverage and finding soft spots in the zone matchups often. Beasley's been so vocal about his wish to be compensated as one of the best slot wide receivers in the NFL, and against the Jacksonville Jaguars, he looked like one of the best slot receivers in the NFL.

Third ✭

Randy Gregory

There are several players, as well as the offensive line, who could have been the third star from Sunday's victory over the Jaguars, but I think Randy Gregory deserves mention here.

We all know Gregory's story at this point.

Randy Gregory had a really good game. He was third on the team in tackles with three, had two tackles for loss, three quarterback hits, and his first sack since January 1st 2017. A total of 651 days. That was week 17 of the 2016 season. Only Leighton Vander Esch and Jaylon Smith had more tackles than Gregory did Sunday.

It's only his second career sack, but what a confidence boost for Gregory who has worked really hard on his sobriety to get himself in a position to play in the NFL.

✭ ✭ ✭ ✭ ✭

After a tremendous win against the Jacksonville Jaguars, the Dallas Cowboys remain only a half game back in the NFC East divisional race. They'll have a chance to take the lead in the division next week as they travel to Washington to play the divisional leading Redskins next Sunday afternoon.

There's no better way to start a Monday than with a Dallas Cowboys victory Monday. Did I leave someone off this 3 Stars list who deserved to be there? Let us know.

Who were your 3 Stars of the Game?

 


Continue Reading



Enjoy 40% commissions on officially licensed products as a FanPrint affiliate. You can even make your own, fully licensed Cowboys and player designs! Get started here

Trending