Top-50 Dynasty Fantasy Football League Rookie Rankings

As most of you know I’ve spent most of the last year writing Fantasy Football from a re-draft perspective. Well, now I’m going to start dipping my toe into the dynasty world as well with my first ever attempt to rank the 2017 rookie class for dynasty fantasy football.

I’m a firm go with my gut guy when it comes to making decisions on players. Sure, I look at the production, the situation, and the history of the team, but in the end, if all things are equal, I let my instincts lead me.

1. Joe Mixon, RB, Cincinnati Bengals

Dynasty Rookie Rankings: 1st EditionJoe Mixon certainly comes with a lot of baggage. Had he not been stupid three years ago, he would have likely been the first running back taken in the draft. But he was stupid and so he was taken in the second round.

He brings to the table an elite blend of the size, speed, agility, vision, power, pass catching, and pure athleticism that will make him a feature back before long.

With only the pass-catching and oft-injured Giovanni Bernard, and the plodding and ineffective Jeremy Hill standing in his way, Mixon will take the lead role for the Bengals. Mixon does everything that you want out of a three-down back.

In my own opinion, and the opinion of many others, Mixon was the best back in the draft.

2. Leonard Fournette, RB, Jacksonville Jaguars

I have such mixed feelings on Leonard Fournette. On the one hand the speed + power combination that he has is nasty and impressive. Those two traits are elite. He has also performed well as a pass blocker. The issue I have is wondering if he’ll be able to make people miss.

You can’t run over everyone in the NFL and while he will be effective, I wonder how many big plays we will see out of him. TJ Yeldon appears to be in the pass catching role for the Jaguars, securing 50 catches, which was third on the team.

Fournette projects to be an excellent back in the NFL, but his situation and my reservations (and yes, I’m in the minority on that one) have him second for me.

3. Corey Davis, WR, Tennessee Titans

The top wide receiver in the draft, Corey Davis, went to a team that was in need of a front line pass catcher. It seems that they have him.

While Davis is making the jump from smaller school competition to the NFL, he shows an ability to get open using vision and awareness that is unmatched. Not solely relying on his athleticism, though he has it, he uses solid route running and zone awareness to find weak spots in the secondary to make plays.

4. Dalvin Cook, RB, Minnesota Vikings

Dalvin Cook was an interesting name to follow during the college football season and during the draft process.

To most observers last season, Cook was considered the top running back in the 2017 rookie class. During the pre-draft process, a lot of concerns began to come out about his checkered past and his shoulder that began to move him down several draft boards. On top of all that, he had about as poor a showing at the NFL combine as you can have for an elite back.

I know many have moved Christian McCaffrey above Cook, and that’s a reasonable decision. My problem though is that McCaffrey saw his draft stock sky-rocket during the draft process while Cook saw his plummet. I think it’s okay to be a bit wary of guys who were considered second rounders in the beginning end up as top-10 draftee.

And vice versa, I think that we can question Cook’s fall from grace as a potential top-10 talent to a second round draft pick.

Despite Cook’s poor performance in the athletic testing, his game film and production indicates that he is an elite talent at running back who is able to be productive in every facet of an offense.

Cook doesn’t have anything standing in his way to becoming RB1 for the Minnesota Vikings, a team that needs more consistency from their running game.

5. Christian McCaffrey, RB, Carolina Panthers

This was by far the best landing spot possible for Christian McCaffrey.

While he showed he has the ability to run in a pro-style power running offense — like he did at Stanford — his athleticism fits much better in an offense that tries to use spacing, speed, and misdirection (run-pass option) like Carolina does.

Their use of Cam Newton’s running ability in the run-pass option game will be a big benefit to McCaffrey, who will be able to run against one less defender who has to account for Newton’s running ability.

McCaffrey is probably the best pass catching back in this rookie class, and he’ll likely get opportunities that way. The problem is that Carolina only targeted running backs on 12% of its pass plays. Compare that to New England who targeted running backs 23% of the time and the Detroit Lions did so 19% of the time. Six running backs were targeted more than Carolina’s entire backfield.

The point is that if McCaffrey is going to get targets, Cam Newton and the Carolina offense are going to have to make it a priority.

6. Mike Williams, WR, San Diego Chargers

An elite talent with elite production at the highest level, Mike Williams may turn out to be the best wide receiver in the class. He certainly has the athleticism and play making ability to work with.

The thing that has me down on him would be his landing spot. There are pretty solid to really good pass catchers with the Chargers already. Keenan Allen, Tyrell Williams, and Hunter Henry can be pretty dynamic at times.

That doesn’t mean that there isn’t room for Williams, in fact he may actually start from day one, but there are several mouths to feed in the Chargers offense.

If you draft Williams, do so based on the long-term expectations and not the short-term. In the short-term, he may be hindered by his teammates.

7. David Njoku, TE, Cleveland Browns

OJ Howard may be a better tight end right now than David Njoku, but he doesn’t have the pure athletic ability that Njoku has and he doesn’t have the same path to offensive production that Njoku does.

Howard is going to have Mike Evans, DeSean Jackson, Cameron Brate (2016’s TE touchdown leader), Charles Sims (a highly targeted running back) and fellow draftee Chris Godwin to compete with for targets.

Njoku has Corey Coleman, Kenny Britt, Duke Johnson and Isaiah Crowell. While yes, it is Cleveland, I like this situation much better in 2017 and long-term.

8. OJ Howard, TE, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

OJ Howard, to me, was the best tight end in the draft by far. He already has NFL-ready blocking ability, athleticism, and pass catching ability. Like I mentioned above, I just don’t like his situation as much.

Howard has a lot of players to compete with in Tampa Bay for targets.

While it’s likely that he will get a lot of playing time, his fantasy football potential is going to be limited by the great players he has around him.

9. Samaje Perine, RB, Washington Redskins

If someone has a chance to be the 2017 version of Jordan Howard, to me it’s Samaje Perine.

Like Howard in 2016, Perine was drafted after the top name running backs and drafted into a situation where the coaching staff is talking up the incumbent starter.

Perine is a better version of Rob Kelley. He runs with the same power that Kelley runs with, but in my opinion has better quickness and elusiveness. Perine is also great at catching the ball out of the backfield, giving him three down potential.

Aside from a poor showing in the 40 yard dash at the combine, I see Perine as every bit the running back that the top-tier guys are.

10. Alvin Kamara, RB, New Orleans Saints

Receiving Jamaal Charles like comparisons pre-draft, Alvin Kamara couldn’t have gone to a better place, unless he was drafted by Kansas City.

Sean Payton and the New Orleans Saints have the creativity and the willingness to use a dual threat running back like Kamara. I expect him to be deployed sporadically in his first year, but by year two should be used in a similar fashion to Reggie Bush and will likely take over as the primary running back in the Big Easy.

11. John Ross, WR, Cincinnati Bengals

Elite speed and athleticism are going to make him an amazing weapon on the other side of the field from AJ Green. Defenses are going to have a really tough time stopping this offense and Andy Dalton immediately gets a bump in re-draft leagues.

12. Juju Smith-Schuster, WR, Pittsburgh Steelers

One of my favorite wide receivers in this year’s draft, Juju Smith-Schuster has all of the tools to be an alpha male wide receiver in the NFL. He displays size, speed, hands, jumping ability, athleticism, and is only 20 years old.

The reason he has dropped so far in my rookie ranks is the massive hill he has to climb up the Steelers depth chart to have an impact in 2017 and in the future.

Antonio Brown, Martavis Bryant, Sammie Coates, and Eli Rogers will likely be ahead of him on the depth chart to start. That doesn’t mean he can’t pass those guys, but again it’s a massive hill to climb.

Dynasty Rookie Rankings: 1st Edition 1

13. Zay Jones, WR, Buffalo Bills – Amazing production at East Carolina, but will it translate to the NFL? Tyrod Taylor hopes so.

14. Evan Engram, TE, New York Giants – Great player with great athleticism, but where are the targets going to come from?

15. Marlon Mack, RB, Indianapolis Colts – Frank Gore could play forever, but it isn’t likely. Marlon Mack is the next man up.

16. Kareem Hunt, RB, Kansas City Chiefs – Hunt will be thrust into a running back competition with incumbent starter Spencer Ware. He has an opportunity to earn some snaps this offseason.

17. Curtis Samuel, RB/WR, Carolina Panthers – A Percy Harvin/Tyreek Hill type will need the Carolina offense to get creative to utilize him and McCaffrey on the field at the same time.

18. D’Onta Foreman, RB, Houston Texans – May not have much of a path to touches in year one, but if Lamar Miller has another below average year and injuries, Foreman is the lead back in 2018.

19. Carlos Henderson, WR, Denver Broncos – One of the more underrated players, likely because he played at Louisiana Tech, the Broncos found a guy that can grow with their young quarterbacks while taking snaps in the slot immediately.

20. Jeremy McNichols, RB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers – A late round pick with promise. The Bucs running back depth chart doesn’t have much standing in the way of McNichols.

Dynasty Rookie Rankings: 1st Edition 2
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback, Patrick Mahomes

21. Chris Godwin, WR, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
22. Taywan Taylor, WR, Tennessee Titans
23. ArDarius Stewart, WR, New York Jets
24. Jamaal Williams, RB, Green Bay Packers
25. Patrick Mahomes, QB, Kansas City Chiefs
26. Cooper Kupp, WR, Los Angeles Rams
27. Wayne Gallman, RB, New York Giants
28. Deshaun Watson, QB, Houston Texans
29. Mitch Trubisky, QB, Chicago Bears
30. Dede Westbrook, WR, Jacksonville Jaguars

  • In this group I think that Jamaal Williams and ArDarius Stewart are going to have the biggest impact aside from the quarterbacks.
  • While Deshaun Watson and Mitch Trubisky will get a chance to play year one, Patrick Mahomes is my favorite quarterback from this class.
  • Cooper Kupp was a pre-draft darling for a lot of people and he goes to a situation that is devoid of wide receivers.
  • Godwin, Taylor, and Westbrook are all going to be good NFL wide receivers, but their situations make their 2017 and future outlook a bit dicey. Taylor has the best shot for year one impact.
Dynasty Rookie Rankings: 1st Edition 3
Russ Isabella – USA TODAY Sports

31. KD Cannon, WR, San Francisco 49ers
32. Chad Hansen, WR, New York Jets
33. Joe Williams, RB, San Francisco 49ers
34. Amara Darboh, WR, Seattle Seahawks
35. Chad Williams, WR, Arizona Cardinals
36. Josh Reynolds, WR, Los Angeles Rams
37. Isaiah Ford, WR, Miami Dolphins
38. DeShone Kizer, QB, Cleveland Browns
39. Jake Butt, TE, Denver Broncos
40. Kenny Golladay, WR, Detroit Lions

  • From this group of players, I like Jake Butt the best. If not for the injury to Butt, he would have likely been a top-50 draft pick. Will have a chance to play when healthy.
  • San Francisco’s Head Coach admitted that the 49ers went off the board for running back Joe Williams, which leads me to believe that Carlos Hyde’s days are numbered.
  • Isaiah Ford has a chance to push DeVante Parker for a starting wide receiver spot in Miami.
  • Chad Hansen has a chance to play early if he can beat out Quincy Enunwa or Robby Anderson while Eric Decker is on the shelf.
Dynasty Rookie Rankings: 1st Edition 4
Los Angeles Rams tight end, Gerald Everett.

41. Adam Shaheen, TE, Chicago Bears
42. Elijah McGuire, RB, New York Jets
43. Gerald Everett, TE, Los Angeles Rams
44. Donnel Pumphrey, RB, Philadelphia Eagles
45. Malachi Dupre, WR, Green Bay Packers
46. Jonnu Smith, TE, Tennessee Titans
47. Bucky Hodges, TE, Minnesota Vikings
48. Davis Webb, QB, New York Giants
49. Josh Malone, WR, Cincinnati Bengals
50. Jordan Leggett, TE, New York Jets

  • Shaheen is one of the more intriguing prospects, a player who brings three-technique defensive tackle size in an athletic tight end. If he can adapt to NFL competition, there won’t be anyone that can cover him.
  • McGuire will have a chance for a few snaps this season, but look for 2018 to be his breakout.
  • Everett and Leggett will have a chance to play early and often as neither has imposing tight ends on their respective depth charts.

Feel free to let me have it in the comment section or on Twitter @john9williams.

What do you think?


Written by John Williams

Dallas Cowboys optimist bringing factual, reasonable takes to Cowboys Nation and the NFL Community. I wasn't always a Cowboys fan, but I got here as quick as I could.

Make sure you check out the Inside The Cowboys Podcast featuring John Williams and other analysts following America's Team.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Cowboys en Español:

Cowboys Rookies Are Unlikely to be Day 1 Starters

Football Theory 1: Gaps and Techniques 1

Schemes and Concepts Chapter 1: Gaps and Techniques