It would seem difficult to analyze the Dallas Cowboys’ draft strategy over the last few years to see what tendencies they have. However, the team’s front office has been steadfast on several draft strategies.
Jerry Jones and company are creatures of habit. They do not like change and will do whatever it takes to make themselves look like geniuses.
Since Mike McCarthy has been the head coach, an emphasis on certain positions has been a priority, but not being able to sign a big-time free agent has put more pressure on the coach to draft players who can play right away.
Drafting plug-and-play players is difficult, but the Cowboys’ draft tendencies show that they try their hardest to find instant starters.
First Round Tendencies
Jones and McCarthy are unwavering in their commitment to prioritizing premium positions in the first round.
Since McCarthy joined in 2020, the team has decisively focused on strengthening the offensive and defensive lines, as evidenced by impactful selections like Micah Parsons and Tyler Smith.
They strategically, or not so strategically, refuse to trade up aggressively, instead opting to remain at their draft position and consistently selecting the best available talent.
Recent early draft picks clearly show their strong preference for players from Power Five conferences, particularly the Big Ten, SEC, and Big 12.
Offensive Philosophy
Continuity on the offensive line is paramount for this team.
They have a proven track record of selecting top offensive linemen early, demonstrated by picks like Tyron Smith, Travis Frederick, Zack Martin, Tyler Smith, and Tyler Guyton.
The team clearly favors complete wide receivers who contribute in multiple dimensions rather than merely speedsters. This can be seen in CeeDee Lamb and Jalen Tolbert, who are not known for their speed.
They seem to favor not drafting running backs, which is essential to their strategic framework, that is, not having a running game.
Defensive Preferences
The emphasis on defensive line rotation and pass rushers is a driving force behind their draft choices.
They aggressively pursue linebacker/edge hybrid players who exhibit the flexibility to succeed in different schemes. Micah Parson, Osa Odighizuwa, and Marcus Kneeland are prime examples.
Cornerbacks with length and strong press-man skills take precedence, and they intentionally address the safety position in the later rounds to maximize their early-round resources.
They tend to draft safeties who are more special teams players and develop them into rotational pieces like Israel Mukuamu.
Late Round Strategy
In rounds 5-7, they target players primed to make an immediate impact on special teams.
The team diligently develops offensive linemen late in the draft, consistently unearthing value in defensive backs chosen in later rounds—an area where they excel.
They confidently take calculated risks on players with prior injuries in these later rounds, hoping to find a player with an earlier draft grade late in the draft.
The Cowboys scouts seem to be more than capable of finding players who can contribute in the later rounds. This has been a trend over the last several years.
Key McCarthy Influences
The strategy is firmly rooted in a pronounced emphasis on offensive versatility.
They dismiss any candidates lacking a strong football IQ and scheme fit. Only players capable of contributing across multiple game phases are considered.
Leadership traits and a good pedigree from successful programs are non-negotiable requirements.
Overall Draft Philosophy
The Cowboys are resolute in their approach; they do not draft for immediate needs but operate with a clear long-term vision.
They steadfastly adhere to the “best player available” strategy.
Physical traits and athleticism are vital components of their evaluation, reinforcing their preference for players from winning college programs. They understand the importance of a competitive background.
Character and leadership qualities are fundamental to most selections.
As we look toward the 2025 draft, we can assertively predict that the Cowboys will:
– Actively pursue offensive line reinforcements early if any starters leave.
– Seek depth along the defensive line throughout the draft process.
– Focus on acquiring versatile linebacker talent.
– Strengthen the secondary in the middle rounds.
– Add receiving threats if notable players exit.
Under the leadership of Jones and McCarthy, the Cowboys have established a clear and patient approach, letting the draft unfold before them rather than forcing picks.
This strategy has proven successful, yielding standout talents like Micah Parsons and CeeDee Lamb, who fell into their hands.