More

    Using Win Probabilities To Evaluate Decision Making: Cowboys Kick Vs. Raiders

    The have surpassed the in more ways than one, but on Sunday, their willingness to “be aggressive” and “take chances” shined through the most. Eagles head coach was congratulated by the masses for not scared, and instead going for it on key fourth downs and even attempting trick plays.

    When you really evaluate those decisions, however, they shouldn't even be thought of as “risky.” If anything, they were simply the obvious call.

    Over the last few months I have been working with models, looking to validate and refine those available to the public. I can't share too much about the work as of yet (there will hopefully be a published article in the future), but the work is certainly promising.

    What I can say is this. Dennis Lock and Dan Nettleton worked to utilize random forests to estimate win probabilities before each play in an NFL game. These “forests” are similar to decision tree machine learning, cycling through random trees of past data to predict future outcomes.

    Brian Burke has been utilizing his model for a while now, and Pro Football Reference has a simple, yet effective model as well. For my project, I have been working to find the “best” ways to estimate those win probabilities in order to inform decision making by head coaches and coordinators.

    If you aren't utilizing correctly in today's NFL, you're falling behind. And if you aren't willing to take calculated risks based off of what these numbers say and mean, you are really falling behind.

    How does this all relate to the Cowboys?

    Well, has been pretty consistent in their main criticism of head coach Jason Garrett: he's too conservative. They say he coaches scared, and they believe he punts the ball away too often between the 40's. Numbers accumulated by writers such as Bob Sturm and Marcus Mosher back up these claims, but I wanted to examine Garrett's decision making through the win probability lens.

    I took to to ask the fan base for specific scenarios in which they felt Garrett was too conservative. Then, I ran these situations through the win probability model to determine how these decisions affected the outcomes.

    Over a series of posts I will detail what the model says about the Cowboys' decision making in these key moments. First, we go back to December of last season where the Cowboys had their season on the line in Oakland.

    Cowboys at Raiders, 2017

    One instance which was consistently brought up was ironically from a Cowboys win. Yes, a win!

    The Raiders had played the Cowboys close all game long, and with their season on the line Dallas was in position to put those pesky Raiders away. Tied at 17 they entered a fourth and goal situation at the Raiders' 1 yard line. The Cowboys decided to kick the field goal and grab a 20-17 lead. While Dallas did hang on to win, this was only because of a miraculous play by which resulted in a fumble and a touchback.

    Many of the fans who tweeted at me seem to think the Cowboys should have went for the touchdown on fourth down, rather than take their three points. But what does the model say?

    - Advertisement -

    Prior to the fourth down play, the Cowboys had about an 85% chance to win the game. After kicking the field goal and kicking the ball away to Oakland, that probability went down to just above 80%. Had the Cowboys gone for it and been stuffed at the Raiders' 1 yard line, that probability would have dropped all the way to just over 57%.

    But the model does believe that Garrett made the right decision. Of course, had Dallas scored a touchdown, the game would've virtually been over, but the variance in probabilities suggests that kicking the field goal and taking the sure points was a good move.

    Next week, I explain where Jason Garrett and company may have gone wrong during a key 4th down decision against the . If you have any suggestions for plays/situations you'd like evaluated, please comment below!

    spot_imgspot_imgspot_img
    Kevin Brady
    Kevin Bradyhttps://kevinrobertbrady.wordpress.com
    Die-hard Cowboys fan from the Northeast, so you know I am here to defend the 'boys whenever necessary. Began writing for a WordPress Cowboys Blog, and have been with ITS since 2016.

    Latest

    Like it or Not, It’s Time to Give the Front Office Credit

    All of a sudden the Cowboys have won three...

    Brett Maher Continues to Kick With Confidence

    A topic of conversation throughout the offseason was who...

    Is It Time For Dallas To Trust Cooper Rush?

    Now that Quarterback Cooper Rush is 4-0, lots of...

    DAL 25, WAS 10: Defense Dominates Commanders to Earn 3rd Straight Victory

    Four field goals by Brett Maher and touchdowns from...

    Newsletter

    Daily Cowboys News in Your Inbox
    Name:*
    Your email address:*
    Please enter all required fields Click to hide
    Correct invalid entries Click to hide

    Don't miss

    Like it or Not, It’s Time to Give the Front Office Credit

    All of a sudden the Cowboys have won three...

    Brett Maher Continues to Kick With Confidence

    A topic of conversation throughout the offseason was who...

    Is It Time For Dallas To Trust Cooper Rush?

    Now that Quarterback Cooper Rush is 4-0, lots of...

    DAL 25, WAS 10: Defense Dominates Commanders to Earn 3rd Straight Victory

    Four field goals by Brett Maher and touchdowns from...

    Halftime Report: WR Michael Gallup Scores in his Return, Cowboys Lead Commanders 12-7

    After two-quarters of a classic-NFC East battle, the Dallas...

    It is Now or Never for McCarthy to Prove His Worth

    Just like that the Cowboys are seeing their season flash before their eyes after an all-time bad season opener that has Dallas in shambles...

    Who Could Be The Next Head Coach After McCarthy?

    We all know that the coaching staff hasn't been very solid for the Dallas Cowboys the last two seasons. Lots of the blame has...

    Mike McCarthy Ranked Among Bottom Half of NFL Head Coaches

    Assessing Mike McCarthy's actual value as a coach has been a hot topic for several years now. At least one major sports outlet doesn't...