Connect with us

Star Blog

Would Trading La’el Collins for Earl Thomas Make Sense?

Mauricio Rodriguez

Published

on

#DALvsOAK: RT La'el Collins Faces Toughest Challenge In Preseason Week 3
Vernon Bryant / The Dallas Morning News

Let me start this off by saying that if I were in charge of the Dallas Cowboys' decisions, I wouldn't pull the trigger on a trade like this. Even still, a La'el Collins for Earl Thomas trade scenario is worth discussing after having spent the entire offseason talking and daydreaming about the possibility of seeing the All-Pro safety wear the Star in 2018. Let's think outside the box for this one.

The Cowboys' young and unproven defense has plenty of talent in most positions, but no matter how optimistic you are, there's clearly concerns around the safety position in Dallas. Former Seahawks' DC Kris Richard's arrival is promising, but Jeff Heath, Xavier Woods and Kavon Frazier have a long way to go before being labeled as a good unit.

It's been established that the Cowboys have an actual interest in upgrading the position by acquiring  Earl Thomas. At least they tried to get him during the 2018 NFL Draft when they talked to Seattle about making the trade but the negotiations went nowhere.

Cowboys en Español: Hablemos de Earl Thomas, la NFL Sigue Equivocándose

Seattle Seahawks S Earl Thomas  (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

Sitting here months later, the rumors haven't calmed down since Thomas has done nothing to stop them by remaining a no-show to Seahawks' offseason programs. Training camp is just weeks away and if he keeps his holdout alive, the Cowboys might shoot an offer.

We've been discussing second-round picks and third-round picks all this time but to switch it up, let's discuss the possibility of trading a player. Specifically, La'el Collins.

The Cowboys could use a safety to take their defense to the next level and the Seahawks could use a young talented RT as a piece to rebuild their disastrous offensive line.

For the Cowboys, the pro is logically the fact that they'd have an All-Pro safety like Earl Thomas on defense. The Cowboys are loaded with talent on this side of the ball, but they need a difference maker on the field like Thomas. With him starting football games for the team, Dallas has the potential to be a top 10 defense.

Kris Richard would be getting a player that he's known for years and could exploit his talents in a fresh secondary. Thomas would also bring a veteran presence that might be required in such a young defensive backfield as well.

The con is losing a right tackle who could start for another 10 years. Now, many overlook Collins' performance just because of the players he's standing next to, but he was outstanding as a tackle in 2017. Clearly, he will be a very important asset for the Cowboys and one that will last a long time, just like the rest of the offensive line.

If a scenario like this took place, Cameron Fleming would do a decent job at best, but that might be more than enough for this offense. Fleming didn't struggle much in his time at New England. The real concern would be at the "swing tackle" position, where we'd probably be talking about guys like Chaz Green.

Finally, Thomas, 29 years old, would sign a contract with the team and play for a very limited amount of years before hanging up the cleats.

All in all, I wouldn't make a trade like this. Then again, I wouldn't hate the front office for making such a move. Thomas is one of those players who could come into Dallas and give it a legitimate threat in the NFC East. He'd make the Cowboys' defense one that's ready for a Super Bowl run.

However, the offensive line will be a very important thing for Dak Prescott, who will play his third year in the NFL with a lot to prove after a 9-7 season last year. The front office's approach has been clear in the last few years. The offensive line is obviously a priority over Earl Thomas.

Lastly, I leave you with the results of a poll I conducted on Twitter to see what Cowboys Nation had to think. Let me know your thoughts on the comments section below!

Mauricio Rodriguez ✭ on Twitter

Hey @CowboysNation, would you trade La'el Collins for Earl Thomas? I wouldn't, but the question was brought up to me and thought it was interesting. Interested in hearing your takes. ✭

Tell me what you think about "Would Trading La’el Collins for Earl Thomas Make Sense?" in the comments below, or tweet me @PepoR99 and let’s talk football! If you like football and are looking for a Dallas Cowboys show in Spanish, don’t miss my weekly Facebook Live! show, Primero Cowboys!



I love to write, I love football and I love the Dallas Cowboys. I've been rooting for America's team all the way from Mexico ever since I can remember. If you want to talk football, I'm in... You'll find me at @PepoR99.

Advertisement
11 Comments
  • Travis Diggs

    Not at all .He’s too important to this line .If your gonna trade a lineman then you trade Chaz Green or Joe Looney but Collins is a definitive no

  • Nick Russo

    No chance. Like yo mentioned Collins is a worthy starting tackle in this league and will be for many years to come. People don’t pair him with the big 3 (smith, Fredrick, Martin) because he ended up going undrafted and has played 2 positions. But this guy was a first round talent coming out of LSU. As good as Earl Thomas is, he is going to be on the back half of his career and is a big salary to carry. Saftey might not be great right now but with this O-line we can control the tempo of the game and the rest of our defense should be able to pick up the “slack” at saftey.

  • William Pep Hatcher

    If we traded Collins we’d be one OL injury away from another 9-7 year.

  • Smitty

    Send ’em Chaz “Bono” Green and a #3.

  • Hector Espindola

    No way, Dak would be lost!

  • Emilio Gonzalez

    No

  • Emilio Gonzalez

    No.Thanks

  • Ismael Ramirez

    No no no

  • oneputter

    makes about as much sense as hiring a boob dancer with no boobs.

  • Josh Knepshield

    How can you say he was outstanding when he was one of the worst OL in the league according to PFF. I know teams overestimate their own players, but this is stupid.

  • Dennis Boggs

    no way in the world do the cowboys make that trade! Collins is a beast, on that line, he,s one of those players the cowboys talk about being the right kind of person! Collins is a true blue cowboy!

Star Blog

Starters Make Cowboys Serious Contenders, But Depth is a Concern

Mauricio Rodriguez

Published

on

Cowboys Defense Better Or Worse Then Last Season?

Playing in the National Football Conference, the Dallas Cowboys have a difficult task ahead of them if they are to be serious Super Bowl contenders. Even still, they've become a very underrated football team due to their 9-7 record last season. The Cowboys struggled in many areas and with the Philadelphia Eagles crowned as Super Bowl Champions, everyone has forgotten about America's Team.

2017 was an awful year for the Cowboys. It seemed like a roller coaster of success, putting up an impressive performance one week only to disappoint the next one. Let's be honest with ourselves here and talk about what really ended the Cowboys' last season.

Injuries.

As much as we talk about how there shouldn't be any excuses in football - the Eagles made a huge statement by winning it all with a backup QB and other key starters missing - we can't deny the impact of these injuries.

Anthony Hitchens, Sean Lee, Tyron Smith and Ezekiel Elliott all missed some time last year, affecting the team's performance week in and week out. Had the starters been healthy, the truth is this team would've been in the playoffs.

Heading into 2018, the Cowboys will face a very similar situation. This year, starters make Dallas a serious contender. Even if they're playing in a conference that will feature a lot of quality teams, the Cowboys are a team that could beat any team in the league if healthy.

Even the dreaded wide receiver position - which has been famous this offseason for the lack of a #1 receiver - won't be as bad as we make it out to be starter-wise. A starting trio of Allen Hurns, Michael Gallup and Cole Beasley doesn't really sound bad.

Heck, not even Jeff Heath and Xavier Woods starting at safety is concerning. They have what it takes to be decent starters. Sure, Heath isn't a guy who will make the Pro Bowl, but his skills will show on the field once the season starts in September.

The Cowboys' starters will do just fine this season. If the team's fate is up to them, they are in a very good spot. The same can not be said about depth, though.

Except for the defensive line, every other position lacks depth. If Sean Lee goes down, the linebackers stop looking like a three-headed monster. Same goes for the cornerbacks. Byron Jones, Chidobe Awuzie and Jourdan Lewis seem like a good group but as soon as one of them suffers an injury, the Cowboys will be in trouble.

We're in for an exciting season with a lot of young talent waiting to breakout. The Cowboys are underrated this year. They may not be among the NFC's favorites, but they truly have what it takes to replicate the success they had in 2016. However, it seems like circumstances have to be ideal for them to make a run for the Lombardi Trophy.

With a little bit of luck, they'll bounce back this season.

Tell me what you think about "Starters Make Cowboys Serious Contenders, But Depth is a Concern" in the comments below, or tweet me @PepoR99 and let’s talk football! If you like football and are looking for a Dallas Cowboys show in Spanish, don’t miss my weekly Facebook Live! show, Primero Cowboys!



Continue Reading

Star Blog

The Dallas Cowboys WR Position Battle is Heating Up

Brian Martin

Published

on

Dallas Cowboys WR Position Battle Heating Up 1

Earning a spot on the Dallas Cowboys final 53-man roster is going to be a lot tougher in 2018 then it has been in years past. There is no shortage of position battles taking place right now to earn one of those coveted openings, but it's the battle taking place at receiver that's gaining steam and starting to heat up.

The ultimate unknown right now is how many wide receivers the Dallas Cowboys choose to carry on their 53-man roster this season. Last year they decided to carry six, but they have been known to carry just five. Unfortunately, this means they will have to release some talented players and risk losing them to another team.

As things stand right now there may just be one, possibly two, roster spots up for grabs. I think the only thing we know for sure right now is Cole Beasley, Allen Hurns, Michael Gallup, and Tavon Austin are the only WRs who can feel secure their jobs are safe for 2018. Everybody else is playing a game of Survivor, just hoping their name isn't the one written down and their torch isn't snuffed out.

Terrance Williams' flame may be safe due to his current contract. The Dallas Cowboys can't save anything by releasing him, but it doesn't cost them that much either. It's unlikely he has a future with the team, so if someone were to prove themselves more worthy, his flame could be extinguished.

Terrance Williams

Dallas Cowboys WR Terrance Williams

Last season I thought Noah Brown was ready to unseat Williams, but that never really materialized. Unfortunately, Brown hasn't really shown up as much as I thought he would this offseason, and missing the game against the San Francisco 49ers last week didn't do him any favors either. This doesn't bode well for him moving forward.

Deonte Thompson was signed as a free agent to provide some veteran experience and speed to the passing game, but that in no way means his job is secure. He needs to do something to show up a little more because his age and salary means a younger up-and-coming WR could make him expendable.

Second-year WR Lance Lenoir Jr. might just be the receiver who has stirred things up the most. He has not only created a buzz for himself in offseason practices, but he was able to carry it over into the preseason last week against the 49ers. His arrow trajectory is definitely pointing upwards.

I'd definitely hate to be the one to decide who stays and who goes when final cuts are made. It's not going to be an easy decision to make, because the outcome will definitely have an impact on the team's success this year.

All of these players were brought into help Quarterback Dak Prescott and the passing game reach new heights, so making the wrong move could be detrimental. The number of wide receivers and who the Dallas Cowboys decide to keep might be the most important decision they make before the season starts.

How would you predict the Dallas Cowboys WR position battle turning out?



Continue Reading

Star Blog

Any Concern About Dan Bailey Not Playing Against 49ers?

Brian Martin

Published

on

Decision not to Play Dan Bailey against the 49ers a Concern? 1

With all the excitement of the Dallas Cowboys finally playing in a game last week against the San Francisco 49ers, it may have escaped your attention that Dan Bailey remained on the sideline the entire time. He didn't attempt one field goal or kick off once last Thursday, which in my opinion is a little concerning.

Dan Bailey joined Ezekiel Elliott and Sean Lee on the sideline as a healthy scratch last week. The decision to sit both Zeke and Sean Lee makes sense due to the physical demands of their positions, but sitting Bailey was a bit of a head scratcher. After all, it's not like he plays a physically demanding position like the other two.

I know. I know. Dan Bailey is an integral part for the Cowboys success moving forward. I'm not arguing that he's not, but after sitting out the majority of the 2017 season with a groin injury and lingering concerns about his health this year, not playing him at all against the 49ers is a bit confusing.

I don't believe there is any kind of kicking competition between Dan Bailey and Brett Maher, who handled all of the kicking duties against the 49ers last Thursday. Bailey will be the Cowboys kicker when the 2018 season gets underway in just a few short weeks. But, the question remains… Why didn't he receive any playing time?

Dan Bailey

Dallas Cowboys K Dan Bailey

Dan Bailey was never quite the same last season once he returned from his injury. Something was off and I don't know if it was more mental or physical, maybe a little of both. He just wasn't splitting the uprights like his normal self.

Unfortunately, we have seen this kind of thing happen in the past with one of the Cowboys kickers. Nick Folk went through a similar situation with an injury and never really bounced back. I'm just hoping history doesn't repeat itself.

Obviously, the Dallas Cowboys know more about what's going on with Dan Bailey than I do. But, you would think they'd have allowed him to attempt a field goal or at least an extra point in a game situation to build up his confidence once again. It's what I would have done.

Hopefully I'm just being a little paranoid and I'm reading more into this than there actually is. But, the fact I haven't heard any reasoning as to why Dan Bailey was held out last week is sitting a little uneasy with me. I'm just hoping it was precautionary in order to keep him as healthy as possible for the upcoming season.

Should we be concerned Dan Bailey was a healthy scratch last week?



Continue Reading



Enjoy 40% commissions on officially licensed products as a FanPrint affiliate. You can even make your own, fully licensed Cowboys and player designs! Get started here

Trending