LikeLike WTFWTF LoveLove HahaHaha AngryAngry

Is The Packers’ 2019 Success An Indictment Of Mike McCarthy?

There’s a collective angst amongst most Cowboys fans.

Being that it’s been nearly 25 years since any level of championship success for America’s Team, the fanbase sits atop the mountain of rabid and paranoid bunches around the league. We look for any shred of hope, but the level of panic Cowboys Nation embodies can certainly get exhausting.

So when newly hired head coach Mike McCarthy’s former team looks way better off without him, that panic starts to creep in.

Following their most disappointing two-year run in the Aaron Rodgers era, Green Bay fired McCarthy, hired Matt LaFleur and began their journey to the NFC title game. It certainly looks like all the Packers had to do in order to get to the place Dallas hasn’t been since 1995/96 was fire the coach the Cowboys just hired.


Green Bay is enjoying life after McCarthy to the tune of a 13-3 season and NFC championship game appearance, but just how much of that has to do with McCarthy’s firing? Well, as usual in the NFL, some level of the Packers’ turnaround can be attributed to the new staff, but certainly not all of it.

Matt LaFleur is an awesome play designer.

Let’s start there. Under McCarthy, the Packers offense got stale in the final years. Once one of the most consistently efficient and explosive offenses in the league, Green Bay fell to 25th and 12th in passing DVOA over his last two years with the team. He and Aaron Rodgers did not get along, and McCarthy’s predictable play calling became a Packers Twitter meme (see: slant/flant combo).

Matt LaFleur is a bit like the anti-Mike McCarthy when it comes to modern play design. In 2018 the Packers ranked 27th in the league in play action rate (20%), but LaFleur’s increased the rate to 27% in one season. This increase has led to some chunk passing plays down the field, something LaFleur was able to generate in Tennessee off play action as well.

Matt Bowen on Twitter

On the Davante Adams TD tonight – Show the crosser, work back to the corner. Tendency breaker off play-action #Packers ran the same concept in Week 2 vs. MIN. Beat 2-deep coverage here. @NFLMatchup

Despite the play action increase, Rodgers’ bread and butter remains the quick game. In fact 68% of the Packers’ dropback passes have been quick drops, indicating that LaFleur has adjusted his offense to match what his quarterback does best.

Where there was tension between McCarthy and Rodgers, the quarterback and his new head coach seem to have found a happy medium in terms of play-calling.

Ted Nguyen on Twitter

Nice play design by LaFleur Double move from the bunch. Concept looks like stick initially. – #1 Runs an out but pivots back inside – #3 Corey Davis runs a hitch-and-go – Also, a possible rub from the point running a crosser which intersects with the backside dig.

He doesn’t get talked about in this way, but what Matt LaFleur has done in terms of offensive design and play-calling is coach of the year type stuff. He’s as creative, smart, and open-minded on offense as advertised, and has allowed the Packers to find their identity over the course of the entire season.

While Rodgers has declined as a consistent passer and playmaker off script, LaFleur has found ways to deploy guys like Aaron Jones to make this offense as effective as possible.

Something Mike McCarthy really wasn’t able to do in 2018.

Don’t worry, though – this isn’t all about a coaching change.

While you may be panicking after the first section of this post, don’t fret too much. LaFleur has been an awesome influence on the formerly stale offense, but maybe the biggest reason for the Packers turnaround is what they did in free agency.

Especially on the defensive side of the ball.

Signing Za’Darius Smith and Preston Smith to massive offseason contracts was largely uncharacteristic for the Packers franchise, but it helped propel them to the heights they’ve reached this season.

The two edge rushers combined for 23.5 sacks in 2019, leading one of the most improved units in all of football. If not for these signings, who knows where the Packers would be this season – even with LaFleur’s influence on the other side of the ball.

Then there’s guys like Kenny Clark, Jaire Alexander, and Darnell Savage – young defensive playmakers that have taken huge steps under Mike Pettine in 2019.

Mike McCarthy has said all the right things during his comeback tour, earning him the job in Dallas and a five year contract. Whether or not it will be a success is yet to be seen, but the success of the Packers post-McCathy does not mean he will fail in Dallas.

This is a totally different team, with a much different (and so far better) staff around him. If McCarthy is serious about implementing new ideas into his offensive strategy, and utilizing analytics to the fullest effect, then he should be able to bring the Cowboys back to the postseason in 2020.

Unfortunately at this point – we just have to wait and see.

What do you think?

Kevin Brady

Written by Kevin Brady

Die-hard Cowboys fan from the Northeast, so you know I am here to defend the 'boys whenever necessary. Began writing for a WordPress Cowboys Blog, and have been with ITS since 2016.


Leave a Reply
  1. 23.5 Ave per game scoring 2019 vs 23.5 2018, stale?

    OTOH, defensive scoring fell from 25 to 19.6.

    GB won because Emergence of Arron Jones, which made their play action game more powerful but largely because they spent money to dramatically upgrade their D.

  2. Mike McCarthy has nothing to do with the 2019 Green Bay Packers. He’s old news. Meanwhile, Coach M. Lefleur has a good shot for the 2019 NFL Head Coach of the Year.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Jason Witten

Could Jason Witten Move Into Open Tight Ends Coach Job With Cowboys?

Making the Playoffs Could do More Harm Than Good For Cowboys

SC’s 2020 Cowboys 7-Round Mock Draft