The Cowboys’ Christian Parker Lost Me Like Miller Lost McCaffrey

Dallas Cowboys defensive coordinator Christian Parker walks the sideline as his defense got manhandled by the San Francisco 49ers.

I spent the last few weeks defending Christian Parker because I thought the Dallas Cowboys defense was finally showing some improvement. I saw players becoming more comfortable, better execution and a defensive coordinator who I thought was figuring it out.

Then Kyle Shanahan came along and made Christian Parker look like he had no business calling an NFL defense.

We watched in utter disbelief the Cowboys could surrender 584 yards and 46 points in Sunday’s 46-40 loss to the San Francisco 49ers. That is, by the way, the most yards Dallas has ever allowed at home.

Brock Purdy threw for 389 yards in a nearly flawless game, sporting a 154.5 passer rating. The 49ers averaged 9.4 yards per play, which is ridiculous because the Cowboys had five sacks.

I’ve criticized plenty of Cowboys players for missed tackles, blown assignments, and poor execution. There was no shortage of that Sunday, but I have a much bigger problem with the decisions being made before the ball is snapped.

ESPN’s Dan Olovsky and Rex Ryan were both blunt in their explanations after they examined the Cowboys’ defensive performance. The criticism was directed at Christian Parker’s inability to find anything that worked against Shanahan.

The @dallascowboys tried everything. All defenses….
6 TDs—6 different defenses
Tweet video thumbnail

Watching as the Dallas defense tried different coverages and pressures without getting any results didn’t convince me Christian Parker was making adjustments. It looked more like a young defensive coordinator running out of ideas.


Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Quinnen Williams sacking San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy.

Five Sacks Shouldn’t Result in 584 Yards

I know, I know, the Cowboys brought down Brock Purdy five times, but the pressure meant almost nothing when San Francisco could erase those negative plays with one completion or a well-designed run.

Three of the 49ers plays accounted for 210 yards and three touchdowns. Christian McCaffrey scored on receptions of 74 and 66 yards, and Deebo Samuel added a 70-yard touchdown on a reverse that fooled the entire defense.

The Cowboys defense is caught WAY out of position as Deebo takes a reverse to the house!

All he had to do was follow his big lead blocker, Brock Purdy.

Tweet video thumbnail

That is almost half of San Francisco’s total offensive production coming from three snaps.

McCaffrey’s first touchdown came after Brock Purdy escaped pressure on third down and found him in open space. Samuel’s reverse showed everyone the defense’s inability to maintain contain or recognize what the 49ers were doing with its misdirection.

I can live with a player losing an individual matchup occasionally, but what I can’t understand is why the Cowboys continue having the same problems with eye discipline, leverage, and communication.

As we know, these aren’t new issues. We have watched this defense struggle with those problems all season, and Christian Parker hasn’t found a way to correct them.

The 49ers didn’t do anything that Shanahan hasn’t been doing for years, and there is film on it. San Francisco was just simply better prepared to take advantage of Dallas’ weaknesses.


Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Quinnen Williams sacking San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy.

Von Miller Covering McCaffrey is Where Parker Lost Me

Dallas just pulled within six points after Dak Prescott found Ryan Flournoy for a touchdown with 3:42 remaining. The Cowboys needed one stop to give the offense another chance.

On second-and-10 from the San Francisco 34-yard line, Christian Parker called Cover 0, bringing pressure and leaving defenders in man coverage.

As we all know, that decision left 37-year-old Von Miller covering Christian McCaffrey. I can’t for the life of me figure out how anyone thought that was a good idea.

Brock Purdy recognized the matchup, completed the short pass over the middle, and McCaffrey was off to the races for a touchdown.

Christian Parker wanted to get to Purdy, and I understand that, but you have sacked the quarterback five times without going Cover 0. Why do it when the stop matters the most? This is a running back who already burned you earlier in the game.

Why would we give him a favorable matchup when you needed one stop?

If Christian Parker expected Miller to handle the McCaffrey assignment, he badly misjudged his personnel. If he thought the pressure would get to Purdy before McCaffrey could get open, he took a risk that didn’t need to happen.

Either way, a terrible decision by Christian Parker.


San Francisco 49ers head coach staring out onto the field as his offense dismantles Cowboys defensive coordinator Christian Parkers defense.

Kyle Shanahan Was Playing Chess While Parker Was Playing Checkers. Or Maybe Tic-Tac-Toe

I’m not really sure what Christian Parker was thinking Sunday, but Kyle Shanahan had a pretty good idea about everything Dallas was going to throw at him.

San Francisco used motion and misdirection to manipulate defenders, take notes Schotty, created favorable matchups, and made the Cowboys defend the entire field.

The 49ers didn’t need to beat Dallas with difficult throws because they were creating chances for easy completions and big gains after the catch.

Deebo Samuel’s 70-yard reverse showed just how easily this defense could be fooled. The Cowboys lost contain, and once Samuel got outside, 9 of the 11 defenders were 40 yards away.

The Cowboys coaching staff knew exactly what the 49ers were going to do and they did it anyway. Schottenheimer discussed the importance of eye discipline before the game.

So, the coaching staff knew what to do but failed miserably in relaying the information to the players, or the players don’t respect them enough to listen. I don’t know which would be worse.

The 49ers scored touchdowns on their first three possessions of the second half. They finished the final two quarters with 340 yards and 29 points after Dallas went into halftime down only 17-16.

I want to know what changed during halftime because whatever Christian Parker came up with didn’t slow down San Francisco. It made things worse.

Shanahan kept attacking the same weakness and Dallas count do nothing about it.

I never expected Christian Parker to out coach Shanahan for an entire afternoon, but I kinda expected the Cowboys to make him work a little harder than that.


Dallas Cowboys quarteback Dak Prescott and wide receiver CeeDee Lamb celebrating after a touchdown versus the San Francisco 49ers.

How Much Longer Can Dallas Afford To Do This?

Dak Prescott threw five touchdowns, George Pickens caught three of them, and the Cowboys scored 40 points against one of the best teams in football and still lost at home.

I’ve been critical of Schottenheimer’s offensive play calling all season, and there are still things about it I don’t like, but when your offense puts up 40 points, I can’t put the loss on that side of the ball.

When the defense gave up 46.

Dallas is now 4-6, and Jerry Jones has continued trying to improve the personnel on a defense that has struggled the entire season. At some point, he and Schottenheimer need to decide if the problem is the players, the system, or the man calling the plays.

I don’t believe every defensive failure can be blamed on Christian Parker, but there were too many times Sunday when the 49ers knew exactly what they wanted to do, and the Dallas defense looked completely unprepared.

I’m not ready to say Christian Parker can’t become a good defensive coordinator, but I am questioning whether Dallas put him in a role before he was ready.

The Cowboys have too much offensive firepower to spend another season watching the defense give away games. Schottenheimer and Jones can keep talking about missed tackles and execution, but somebody needs to start asking about the defensive play calling.

And if Parker needs an experienced coach standing next to him on the sidelines, then put Mike Pettine in his pocket, or better yet, let Pettine call the defensive plays now that he’s up to speed.

If Dallas can do that it will get to the root of the problem.

Was this helpful?

Cody Warren is a sports journalist at InsideTheStar.com, where he has published 302 articles reaching over 1 million readers. He is a Law Enforcement Officer with nearly 20 years of professional service across multiple assignments, bringing investigative rigor and a commitment to factual accuracy to his Dallas Cowboys coverage.

Dallas Cowboys football team logo and branding, promoting free Cowboys news app for fans.

Comments

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Loading comments…
Dark
Light