Cowboys News App [Android]

2023 NFL draft first round: Grading the NFC East


The Eagles entered tonight as the early favorites to have the best of the 2023 Draft among teams. It must be nice to have a GM that can build a team to make the and have a Top 10 pick in the next draft too.

The and certainly showed how to improve your team in the draft tonight. Those two first-round trades were stunningly well done. Mercy…

How did the East teams fare in the opening round this year?

Let's take a look:

2023 NFL draft first round: Grading the NFC East

Philadelphia Eagles (9th/30th)

Philadelphia traded with the Bears to swap the teams' respective picks at #9 and #10. The Eagles gave up a 4th rounder in 2024 to make the move. And did they make it pay off.

They selected DT Jalen Carter out of Georgia.

They needed to fill a huge hole on their after they lost a lot of starters on the defensive side of the ball.

As much as I hate to admit this, the Eagles made a great pick. Dallas is going to find it harder to run the ball against their rivals for years to come.

However, as Chicago went with the next pick, did the Eagles get fleeced out of a 4th rounder next year?

If so, I'm kind of good with that.

The Eagles had two first-rounders tonight and with the 30th pick selected DE Nolan Smith from Georgia. So, in short, the Eagles came into the draft in deep trouble on .

They leave with a very scary defense.

I had the Eagles as an 8-9 team in 2023. Not anymore.

The Eagles, I hate to admit, won the first round of the draft. They get an A+ for the first round.

Washington Commanders (16th)

The Commanders went defense as well, taking Emmanuel from Mississippi State.

He's not a big , but he looks to be a solid Ron Rivera-type player. He will add to their , which they needed to improve.

Let's give the Commanders a B+ for the first round.

New York Giants (24th)

The Giants swapped picks with the Jaguars to pick Defensive Back Deonte Banks from Maryland.

They must have felt Jacksonville was going to pull the trigger on this pick. But if that was the case, why would the Jags down?

Don't ask me to explain war rooms.

I needed to save my sanity and quit trying to do this years ago.

Apparently, Banks impressed at the Combine. I'm not so impressed with it myself. We'll charitably give the Giants a B- as they did at least address a need.

Dallas Cowboys (26th)

The Bills leapfrogged the Cowboys courtesy of the Jaguars and selected . Dallas was forced to go to Plan B after watching the top running backs and fly off the board.

Plan B turned out to be , a defensive out of Michigan.

The Cowboys got killed against the run last year. They won't this year with this pick.

2023 NFL draft first round: Grading the NFC East 1
Mazi Smith

And I'll be very honest, I am deeply relieved that they didn't take a here.

I'll be sending a big thank you card to the Jaguars for trading with the Bills so they could swipe Kincaid.

I'll give the Cowboys an A-, only because they avoided taking a first-round tight end.

Follow me over at Twitter (@rdpaolinelli) to read my live tweets of the first round and my thoughts during the draft during Friday and Saturday's rounds too.

Richard Paolinelli
Richard Paolinelli
Richard has covered sports at all levels - from local, prep, college, and professional - since 1984. He has been a fan of the Dallas Cowboys since 1969. Since retiring as a full-time sports writer in 2013, he has written and published several novels, two dozen short stories and two sports non-fiction books.

COntinue Reading


Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

> Join our team...

-- COWBOYS ANDROID APP --Free Dallas Cowboys News App for Android