The Cowboys ranked 15th in receiver-error incompletions, showing their issue was more about execution than passing volume, and I don’t think the receiver-error ranking explains why they missed the playoffs.
We already know what did that.
The defense was the problem. Dallas gave up too many points, got stuck in too many shootouts, and it forced the offense to play uphill almost every week. That isn’t me letting the offense off the hook, it’s just what the season looked like.
This receiver-error stat is still worth talking about because it brings up a fair question.
Does passing volume make this stat look worse than it really is?
That was my exact thought when I saw the post on X and thought to myself, “That’s where the Cowboys become interesting.”
Dallas Was Middle of the Pack
Warren Sharp ranked all 32 NFL teams by the percentage of pass attempts that ended incomplete because of receiver error. Dallas came in at 15th on the list.
1. Jacksonville Jaguars
2. Denver Broncos
3. Cleveland Browns
4. New York Giants
5. Washington Commanders
6. Chicago Bears
7. New York Jets
8. Atlanta Falcons
9. Kansas City Chiefs
10. Minnesota Vikings
11. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
I don’t see that as a disaster, but it’s also not something I would brag about to my friends.
The Cowboys were basically “Meh”.
At first, I thought it would be easy to say Dallas landed there because it threw the ball so much. The Cowboys ranked third in the NFL in pass attempts per game at 36.7.
I believe that matters to a point. Obviously, the more a team passes, the more chances there are for something to go wrong .
So, passing volume can make a receiver’s errors feel louder.
Throwing the ball 37 times per game, we are going to see more drops wrong routes, spacing issues and miscommunications than they would from a team that barely throws the football. It’s not that complicated.
Volume is an Explanation, Not an Excuse
Here is where I separate explanation from excuse.
Sharp’s ranking was not based on total receiver-error incompletions alone, but based on percentage of pass attempts.
If this was just a raw total, I would be more willing to say Dallas got punished for throwing the ball so often. A pass-heavy offense is naturally going to pile up more passing-game mistakes than a team that leans on the run.
But a percentage stat should always account for volume.
That is why some of the cleanest teams on the list matter, because they were not all low-volume passing teams. Arizona ranked first, Cincinatti was second, Houston was seventh, New Orleans was eighth, and Detroit ranked tenth.
So, while I think high volume passing creates more wide-receiver errors, Arizona and Cincinatti threw the ball more than anyone and still finished among the cleanest in the league. That is the part Dallas can’t get away from.
Passing volume creates the opportunity for more mistakes, but it doesn’t excuse the rate of those mistakes.
The Cowboys Had a Detail Problem
This is where I land with the Cowboys.
Dallas threw it a lot, but that doesn’t give the offense a free pass. The Cowboys were still average in that area.
There were receiver mistakes, drops, sloppy routes, and times Dak Prescott and his receivers were clearly not on the same page. Those plays matter in the grand scheme of this article.
But, they did not define the offense.
The Cowboys still had one of the best offenses in the NFL. They threw it well enough to put stress on the defenses. That’s why I don’t see this ranking as some kind of major indictment on the receivers or the passing game as a whole.
I see it as a detail problem, and for a team trying to win big, details are the difference between a win and a loss.
Dallas was good enough offensively to win games. It just wasn’t clean enough to cover up everything else.
Dallas Has Another Level to Achieve
So does passing volume affect receiver error numbers?
In raw totals, I think so.
In percentage form, not nearly as much.
That’s why Dallas ranking third in pass attempts and 15th in receiver-error rate is worth paying attention to. The Cowboys were not just victims of throwing too much. If volume alone explained the stat, Arizona and Cincinatti would not have been sitting among the cleanest in the league.
The better takeaway is simple. Dallas needs to fix the detail problem and if it does, this offense, as good as it is, can still get to another level and that should scare teams.
Was this helpful?
Comments