More

    Ezekiel Elliott Fumble Highlights Flaw in NFL Review Rules

    A critical moment in the ' loss to the came at the end of the first half, when a fumble by Ezekiel Elliott cost Dallas a scoring opportunity and allowed the Saints to tack on another field goal before the break. The way the fumble was handled by the officials highlights what I feel is a major logic breakdown in the NFL's rules for reviewing plays.

    First off, I do want to give the referees credit for allowing the play to proceed without blowing the whistle. The most egregious problem of all is when a play is blown dead and a potential touchdown is called back, only to see on review that it should have been allowed to continue. I appreciate that the officials tried to avoid that mistake.

    However, that positive now creates a new problem.

    By letting the play unfold, it set the precedent that the ruling on the field was a fumble. And because of how the NFL has structured its review process, the initial ruling on the field becomes paramount.

    As you likely have heard, the rules require “clear and obvious visual evidence” to overturn a call made on the field. This philosophy was designed to preserve the human element of and allow referees to maintain their authority and integrity as part of the game.

    At the same time, though, this also puts a wall around the exact issue that reviews were designed to fix. If you need a system to review plays to fix human error, then why are you simultaneously protecting the same error?

    Why are we neutering the full potential of the play review process?

    Referees, Officials
    NFL Referees

    Let's go back to Zeke's fumble. To be clear, and Elliott himself has already admitted this, he should have never allowed for there to be a question. Even if his knee or elbow hit the ground before the ball came loose, Zeke knows he ultimately allowed the turnover by letting the ball get stripped away.

    But because of how close that call was on even slow-motion replay, the ability to make a definitive ruling in real time was almost impossible. The officials went with a fumble because it allowed the play to develop and avoided cancelling a possible Saints touchdown.

    Again, I get that part. But what happens next is a review process in which that initial call of a fumble now takes significant precedence, and the burden of proof to overturn it is far higher than what qualified the initial ruling.

    We don't know exactly what the review official saw, but let's try and put some metrics to this. Imagine that the initial call was based on a 51-49% level of certainty; the referee could have gone either way but just slightly leaned toward a fumble.

    Now it's reviewed and now that leaning changes. Even if it's now 51% in favor that there's no fumble, the call is going to stand based on that “clear and obvious” language.

    - Advertisement -

    But is that logical? Doesn't a determination made based on review, with different angles and slow motion, give the official a better opportunity to make a judgment call than in the heat of the moment?

    There was nothing clear or obvious about the initial fumble ruling. Why should the review be held to such a significantly higher standard?

    If we're going to take the time to review plays and have these lulls in the action, then at least make a greater effort to call things correctly. I know I sound like a bitter Cowboys homer right now, but this reaction comes from watching years of NFL football and countless matchups between all teams.

    Bottom line; initial calls are more likely to be wrong than review decisions. Get rid of the stringent requirement for overturning calls and be more worried about getting things right, not protecting the officials.

    spot_imgspot_imgspot_img
    Jess Haynie
    Jess Haynie
    Cowboys fan since 1992, blogger since 2011. Bringing you the objectivity of an outside perspective with the passion of a die-hard fan. I love to talk to my readers, so please comment on any article and I'll be sure to respond!

    Latest

    Cowboys WR Noah Brown Is Solidifying His Value

    With back-to-back clutch performances against the Cincinnati Bengals and...

    How Kellen Moore Has Redeemed Himself

    During week one, the Dallas Cowboys faced off against...

    Is Rush Hour Almost Over? Jerry Jones Suggests It Might Be

    Earlier in the week, Cowboys owner Jerry Jones indicated...

    In Rush We Trust? QB2 Keeping Cowboys Afloat Beautifully

    When a starting quarterback goes down with an injury,...

    Newsletter

    Daily Cowboys News in Your Inbox
    Name:*
    Your email address:*
    Please enter all required fields Click to hide
    Correct invalid entries Click to hide

    Don't miss

    Cowboys WR Noah Brown Is Solidifying His Value

    With back-to-back clutch performances against the Cincinnati Bengals and...

    How Kellen Moore Has Redeemed Himself

    During week one, the Dallas Cowboys faced off against...

    Is Rush Hour Almost Over? Jerry Jones Suggests It Might Be

    Earlier in the week, Cowboys owner Jerry Jones indicated...

    In Rush We Trust? QB2 Keeping Cowboys Afloat Beautifully

    When a starting quarterback goes down with an injury,...

    Mike McCarthy Was Right: This Team Is Resilient

    Over two weeks ago, Cowboys fans sat in horror...

    Cowboys Rushing Attack Finds Their Mojo in Victory Over the Giants

    The Cowboys went on the road Monday night and won their second straight game without Dak Prescott. The defense was again dominant, and CeeDee...

    Halftime Report: Cowboys Show Flashes on Both Sides, Lead Giants 6-3

    After two quarters on Monday Night Football, the Dallas Cowboys lead the New York Giants 6-3. While the score indicates a low-scoring affair, the...

    3 Keys To Victory – Dallas Cowboys @ New York Giants

    Cooper Rush and the Dallas Cowboys take on the New York Giants tonight in the first divisional game of the season. The world was caving...

    5 COMMENTS

    5 Comments
    Oldest
    Newest Most Voted
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    Brian Scates

    And the saints didn’t get robbed of going to a super bowl? Yeah we, who dat nation, understand that but now the whole league feels our frustration. Maybe DeMarcus shouldn’t have talked all that shit

    Willie Rogers

    Zeke, & Witten both know to avoid the controversy don’t put the ball on the ground until the whistle blows the play dead, this really applies to Zeke, in Witten’s case a 16 year veteran should know pursuit behind you is coming, & the guy you have smoked for the completion is coming from behind you to knock the ball loose, obviously the Cowboys offense is not on the same page as the coach’s, Kellen Moore’s offensive philosophy had that predictable S.Linehan’s look, plunging Zeke into a stacked line of defender’s that know it’s a run with Zeke, the offensive line played very poor.

    David Levine

    You have a few officials on the field and a few camera men. Maybe the camera men need to be the new officials if their ability to capture the exact details of every play is more important than those of the actual NFL officials on the field.

    Alan Morgan

    In simple terms, NO coaches exploit this flaw and have their D rip balls whenever possible. Knowing the refs are avoiding 5 decades of called back TD issues, NO puts this onus to their benefit. I give them credit and wonder why the other coaches don’t do the same. To me, a way to negate this is to simply give the exploiting team a delay of game penalty. Lose 5 yds repeatedly and you’ll rethink running to the house every play.

    Nate Hunter

    I love it when fans think they can tell players what to do and how to do it lol!! Stfu!!! None of you are professional football players, none of you are professional coaches, your opinions DON NOT FUCKING MATTER, SO SHUT….. THE….. FUCK….. UP!