Sports curses & the Cowboys’ drought: Are more than one at play?

May 18, 2023
5
5 mins read
Sports curses: Are the Cowboys fighting more than one? 4
** FILE ** Retired Yankees slugger Babe Ruth warms up with three bats before stepping to the plate at New York's Yankee Stadium, in an August 21, 1942 photo. He was 40, with a pot belly that couldn't be supported by his spindly legs and a growing realization his career was over. His batting average hovered nearly 200 points below his career mark, and his pitchers were unhappy with his inability to run down even the easiest of fly balls. (AP Photo/Tom Sande, file)

There are a handful of legendary curses in the history of sports. Some teams remain afflicted (Chicago Cubs) while others have managed to break free of them (Boston Red Sox).

But are the Dallas Cowboys currently afflicted with a curse?

Is there more than one?

Could be, especially seeing that they’ve played 27 seasons without winning a Super Bowl or an NFC Championship game.

First, let’s take a look at some of the more notable curses. We’ll even examine one in progress you probably aren’t even aware of.

Then we’ll see if we can find a curse lurking about in Arlington.

The Billy Goat Curse

The Chicago Cubs have struggled against their curse since the 1945 World Series.

Billy Sianis, a huge Cubs fan who owned the Billy Goat Tavern in Chicago at the time, arrived at a game with his pet goat.

He always brought the goat with him to Wrigley Field.

Sports curses: Are the Cowboys fighting more than one? 1

Only this time, his goat was asked to leave and when Sianis refused they were both shown the exit.

Sianis would send a telegram to the Cubs stating they’d never win the World Series.

Here we are 78 seasons later and no championships for the Cubs.

The lesson here? Never disrespect a man’s goat.

The Curse Of The Bambino

This one is more commonly known.

In 1919 the Boston Red Sox traded Babe Ruth to the New York Yankees. It took them 86 years — and many heartbreaks in the Fall Classic — to break it and finally win a World Series.

The Bobby Layne Curse

In 1958, the Detroit Lions sent their star player, Bobby Layne, to the Pittsburgh Steelers.

After having led Detroit to three NFL championships, you might imagine that he was not pleased.

Sports curses: Are the Cowboys fighting more than one?
Bobby Layne

Allegedly, he was said to have claimed that the Lions would not win another title for 50 years. Most Lions’ fans deny the story as a hoax.

But the Lions haven’t won a championship since, and we’re talking 65 years now.

And the Steelers? They won their fifth Super Bowl at Ford Field in Detroit.

The Curse Of The Stolen Cup

Here’s one not many know, and many in Canada — like Lions’ fans — refuse to acknowledge.

Back in 1993, the Montreal Canadiens were down 1-0 in the Stanley Cup Finals to the up-and-coming Los Angeles Kings.

They sent a staffer to break into the Kings’ locker room.

Allegedly, the staffer checked out the Kings’ equipment and found an illegal stick but swears he did not alter any equipment.

Sports curses: Are the Cowboys fighting more than one? 5
Officials prepare to measure Marty McSorely’s stick during Game 2 of the 1993 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs in Montreal.

Having identified the stick, the Canadiens waited until they were down 2-1 late in the second game to use the info.

Getting a penalty called, they tied the game on the power play and won it in overtime.

The call turned the series around and Montreal went on to win the Cup. No team from Canada has won the Cup since.

Teams from Canada are 0-6 in the Finals since 1993.

A suggestion has been made to end the curse. Erase the names of the Canadiens and replace them with the names of the Kings to atone for the shenanigans. So far, my Canadian friends have refused.

They’ll have to wait at least one more year to end the curse.

Good luck with that.

The Cowboys Curse(s)

Which brings us to the curse, or curses, that have plagued the Cowboys since January of 1996.

Like it or not, its been 27 seasons of football played without Dallas making it to the Super Bowl.

Sports curses: Are the Cowboys fighting more than one? 3

Since then, 23 of the other 31 teams have played in the championship game. Add in that the Cowboys haven’t even made it to an NFC title game since then.

Of the 16 NFC teams, only Dallas, Detroit and Washington have failed to play in the NFC Championship game since the 1995 season.

Four AFC teams also have failed to advance to their conference title game — Cleveland, Houston, L.A. Chargers, and Miami.

Clearly, the Cowboys find themselves in the lower quarter of the NFL in championships over the past quarter-century.

But how did they get there?

A few theories have been advanced.

One is that a worker laid a Redskins jersey on the ground at AT&T Stadium before the foundation was poured. But that was years into the Cowboys’ drought.

I doubt anyone is going to rip up the place to get that jersey, if its even there.

Plus the move seems to have backfired as the Redskins no longer exist as the Washington moniker.

The Curse of 22

A reader here recently proffered “The Emmitt Smith Curse.”

Again, this one would have started a few years into the drought but has more legs than the previous theory.

Cardinals RB David Johnson Meets Idol Emmitt Smith for First Time

The Cowboys have lost six of their last seven games against the Cardinals. But that streak did not begin until 2008, four seasons after Smith retired from the NFL.

He was the only Triplett not to play his entire career in Dallas, playing the 2003 and 2004 seasons in Arizona.

But Dallas won the first three meetings against the Cardinals from 2003-2006.

The Cowboys are just 4-7 against Arizona since the Cardinals left the NFC East after the 2001 season. So it seems less likely this curse is what ails the team.

Then there is “The Stadium Curse,” but again does it have any merit?

The Cowboys didn’t depart Texas Stadium until after the 2008 season, a full 12 years into the drought.

If the Almighty were displeased he could no longer watch His team play through the iconic hole in the roof, He took His time showing it. So I think we can discount that one too.

No, it seems there’s just one curse at play here.

It’s the same one that has plagued teams like Washington, Detroit, Cleveland and Miami.

The Owners Curse.

How the Eagles Trade Affects the Cowboys Draft Strategy
Sep 13, 2020; Inglewood, California, USA; Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones looks on against the Los Angeles Rams during the second half at SoFi Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

Suffice it to say that the Cowboys, like the other six NFL teams suffering a championship drought, are suffering from management woes.

There’s only one way to break that kind of curse — pray for new ownership. The sooner, the better.

Richard Paolinelli

Richard Paolinelli

Richard Paolinelli is an award-winning sports journalist with 34 years of professional newsroom experience. His newspaper career (1991–2011) includes the Gallup Independent, Modesto Bee, Gustine Press-Standard, Turlock Journal, Merced Sun-Star, Tracy Press, Patch, and San Francisco Examiner. He received the 2001 California Newspaper Publishers Association Best Sports Story award. Richard has authored two non-fiction sports books and 11 novels. At InsideTheStar.com, he has published 874 articles reaching over 728,000 readers.

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mark
Mark
May 18, 2023 8:56 AM

How about th3 Jimmy Johnson not in the ring of honor curse?

Dave
Dave
May 18, 2023 4:48 PM

The cubs won the series in 2016 ending that curse

Lawrence
Lawrence
May 19, 2023 1:48 AM

Hello Richard! No curses at play in Dallas. Just IGNORANCE and ARROGANCE in abundance!!! Firing Jimmy Johnson was perhaps the STUPIDEST DECISION in Sports History. Jimmy’s teams were Smart, Talented, Efficient, and Deep. from top to bottom. The Cowboys have the Lombardi Trophies to prove it. If Jerry and Stephen Jones were Smart( And They’re Not ) Jimmy Johnson would’ve became the General Manager after his Coaching days were done. He would’ve done a much better job than Jerry Jones believes he’s done. Personally I would’ve preferred having Lincoln Riley as the Head Coach and Dan Quinn running the Defense. This current roster would be closer to the Super Bowl than it is. With Riley in town, Kellen Moore’s Dumb Ass would’ve NEVER had a chance to ruin a good Offense!!!

Abel
Abel
May 19, 2023 10:59 AM
Reply to  Lawrence

Absolutely!!!!!

AlphaPredator
AlphaPredator
Jun 14, 2023 10:21 PM

Great

Cowboys at Chargers: Preseason Preview
Previous Story

Cowboys Schedule: Need to stay ahead of trailing Chargers in series

Should the Dallas Cowboys sign Dalvin Cook
Next Story

Why the Dallas Cowboys should sign Dalvin Cook