Was Cowherd’s criticism of Brian Schottenheimer wrong?

5
Dallas cowboys coach dallas cowboys coach dallas cowboys coach.

In the grand scheme of things, how Brian Schottenheimer wears his hat when he’s at work as head coach of the Dallas Cowboys isn’t a big deal.

But that didn’t stop sports talking head Colin Cowherd from sounding off on his show recently.

For the most part, the reaction has favored Schottenheimer’s choice of headwear. Cowherd has even caught a few “Okay, Boomer” responses.

But is he wrong though?

Note: This writer is a “boomer” as well, so factor that in as we proceed. Also, if Schottenheimer gets Dallas to an NFC title game, he can wear his hat any way he wants.

Back In The Day

Cowherd, like myself and the rest of us decaying dinosaurs, grew up at a time when football had head coaches stalking the sidelines in suits.

Tom Landry rocked a fedora. The Cowboys’ first-ever head coach was known as “The Man In The Hat.”

1980: Danny White’s impossible task begins 4

Gradually, though, the suits went away.

It got so bad at one point that, back in 2007, Mike Nolan had to ask the NFL for permission to wear a suit on the sideline as the 49ers Head Coach to honor his father, Dick Nolan.

Other Sports Have Changed

In baseball, managers used to wear the team’s uniform complete with a number of their own. Basketball coaches also wore suits.

It projected an air of professionalism.

It also commanded respect.

Watch a Miami Dolphins game and see Mike McDaniel walking down the sideline. He looks more like a dad rummaging around at a garage sale than an NFL head coach.

Of course, Bill Belichick’s hoodie was around for a long time before McDaniel’s arrival.

That yard-sale grunge look of Belichick’s has been a scourge on football sidelines for some time.

The only sport that seems immune to the “laying-on-the-couch-on-your-day-off” look is hockey. NHL coaches still show up in suits.

Then again, the NHL is the only league that allows its players to engage in a brawl and remain in the game after a five-minute timeout.

The Real Reason

Of course, the real reason why the NFL has allowed the coaches to dress like bums has to do with money.

Coaches now wear gear with the NFL shield and the team name and/or logo on them. People see the latest swag walking the sidelines and shell out the cash to get it.

Frankly, I’d like to see coaches take a little more pride in their appearance and project an air of professionalism.

But why should they be any different from the rest of society, which seems to have embraced a dumbing down of standards. Maybe Cowherd was right after all.

Now, someone fetch me my Geritol and the rest of you get off my lawn.

Was this helpful?

Richard Paolinelli is an award-winning sports journalist with 34 years of professional newsroom experience. His newspaper career (1991–2011) includes the Gallup Independent, Modesto Bee, Gustine Press-Standard, Turlock Journal, Merced Sun-Star, Tracy Press, Patch, and San Francisco Examiner. He received the 2001 California Newspaper Publishers Association Best Sports Story award. Richard has authored two non-fiction sports books and 11 novels. At InsideTheStar.com, he has published 874 articles reaching over 728,000 readers.

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mike M
Mike M
Aug 7, 2025 7:41 AM

in the days of old, suits were worn to promote the “team” concept – as in the US Military. Dress uniforms were mandatory in most public gatherings. Now, he NFL, as in all sports, it’s individualism. the grunge look, gaudy Jewelry. full body tattoos.
me, me, me!

Siempre
Siempre
Aug 7, 2025 10:42 AM

The Boys were among the most penalized teams for years with Schotty coaching the offense. The issue is that sloppy is as sloppy does. You have to earn the relaxed attitude and Schotty has not earned it. Belachek was not sloppy, He was in his Emperor Palpitine hoody as head of his evil empire .Belachik’s teams did not line up offsides. Schotty just looks sloppy and Dallas lines up offsides.

Cowboys fan
Cowboys fan
Aug 7, 2025 1:53 PM
Reply to  Siempre

The players being penalized for those years wasn’t because of Schotty, he was just the offensive coordinator, and he didn’t even call plays or anything!! He wasn’t even the offensive coordinator the whole time!! Those penalties come down to the head coach not being stricked enough on the players!! The head coach didn’t disciplin the players for making stupid mistakes like that!! Schotty was barely a coach while McCarthy was the head coach, so the penalties wasn’t on him, it was on Mike McCarthy!!

Cowboys fan
Cowboys fan
Aug 7, 2025 1:59 PM

The way I see it is, if they’re allowed to wear what they want then they can wear what they want!! They are grown men, and if they wanna wear a hat backwards while they’re working, then that’s they’re choice!! Nobody should be able to tell a grown man what he can wear and how to wear it!!

Edward Carmichael
Edward Carmichael
Aug 8, 2025 8:41 AM

a Dallas Cowboys fan, since the 70’s let me start by saying Colin Cowherd is a idiot 2nd Brian Schottenheimer is Jerry Jones puppet plain and simple