Upon further review, “The Trade” was a colossal blunder

1 month ago
55
3 mins read
The Trade that sent Micah Parsons to Green Bay has already backfired on the Dallas Cowboys

The 2025 NFL season is officially at the 1/3rd pole now. For the Dallas Cowboys and Green Bay Packers, it has been shaped by “The Trade”.

Just one week before Dallas was to open the season against the Philadelphia Eagles, Jerry Jones traded Micah Parsons off to the Green Bay Packers.

In exchange, the Cowboys received defensive tackle Kenny Clark and two first round picks. So how does the trade stack up after the first six weeks?

A Tale Of Two Franchises

The Green Bay Packers are 3-1-1. The Dallas Cowboys are 2-3-1.

Clearly it is the best of times for one, the worst of times for the other. And there’s your obligatory classical literature reference for the season.

The tie game coming, of course, against each other at the end of September.

Based on the record alone, the advantage goes to Green Bay. The Packers, who already have had their bye week, are percentage points ahead of the Detroit Lions for first in the NFC North.

By comparison, the Cowboys are just one-half of a game ahead of the New York Giants for last place in the NFC East.

Again, advantage Green Bay.

Aside from that wild 40-40 overtime tie against Dallas, the Packers have only allowed 62 total points in its other four games this year.

Parsons has 2.5 sacks, 11 tackles, one tackle for a loss, and eight quarterback hits in five games. He did not start the season-opener, a 27-13 win over the Lions.

Lions, football player, NFL, Green Bay Packers, inside the star, sports, American football, player portrait, stadium background, game day, athlete in action.

While Parsons is behind his usual pace in sacks and tackles this year, he is clearly drawing a lot of attention and freeing up his new teammates.

Green Bay has 12 sacks as a team so far. The Cowboys only have 10.

Advantage, again, Green Bay.

Unrealized Hopes

When Jones pulled the trigger on the trade, he insisted it had improved the Cowboys’ ability to stop the run. This has been an Achilles heel that has tormented Dallas for years.

It was the reason why Dallas reached for defensive tackle Mazi Smith in the first round of the 2023 draft.

Smith proved not to be the answer, sending Jones shopping for a run-stopping defensive tackle.

In 2024 over the full season, the Cowboys finished 29th in rushing yards allowed and 32nd in rushing touchdowns allowed. In 2025 they are 29th and 21st respectively.

But that’s only because in 2025, Dallas is 32nd in passing yards allowed and 31st in passing touchdowns allowed.

In 2024, they were 17th and 24th respectively.

Not only can they still not stop the run this year, they can no longer slow down the opposing team in the air either. Mainly because they have no pash rush.

Micah Parsons, the Cowboys trade bait with Green Bay,  sacks New York Jets quarterback Zach Wilson. (DallasNews.com photo)

The role Parsons once filled by either getting to the quarterback, or drawing enough attention to allow his teammates to get there instead.

Failed Gamble

Jones’ moniker as “The Gambler” was heavily lauded less than two months ago when he stunned the NFL by shipping off his best defensive player.

He said he’d made the team better.

But the current numbers clearly show that he was on the draw. When it came time to show his cards, all he had was ace-high.

Six weeks in and we’ve already seen enough.

The Parsons trade will go down as the worst in franchise history. It might even be the worst blunder in the NFL since the Vikings traded for Herschel Walker.

Richard Paolinelli

Richard Paolinelli

Richard Paolinelli is a sports journalist and author. In addition to his work at InsideTheStar.com, he has a Substack -- Dispatches From A SciFi Scribe – where he discusses numerous topics, including sports in general. He started his newspaper career in 1991 with the Gallup (NM) Independent before going to the Modesto (CA) Bee, Gustine (CA) Press-Standard, and Turlock (CA) Journal -- where he won the 2001 Best Sports Story, in the annual California Newspaper Publishers Association’s Better Newspapers Contest. He then moved to the Merced (CA) Sun-Star, Tracy (CA) Press, Patch and finished his career in 2011 with the San Francisco (CA) Examiner. He has written two Non-Fiction sports books, 11 novels, and has over 30 published short stories.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

55 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mike
Mike
Oct 17, 2025 6:20 AM

There is absolutely no way you can know the results of the trade until the draft picks from the trade have been used. You really need to do a better job of critical thinking before you write such nonsense.

DubBe
DubBe
Oct 17, 2025 2:57 PM

Look at Cody’s recent post on this very site. The rush IS getting there, its the coverage that allows for quick throw’s that’s at fault… but what do I know…

Siempre
Siempre
Oct 17, 2025 4:14 PM
Reply to  DubBe

Exactly. This site showed the pass rush is good . The issue is the soft zone allows first read throws to open guys in under 2.5 seconds .

Cano
Cano
Oct 18, 2025 2:51 PM

Let me explain it to you like you are a 10 year old. We all love Micah Parsons but Kelly plus two first round draft picks. Granted we have to see what is available and if they are going to get at least another pass rusher. Definitely 3 and 2 that are new defensive line bodies that are hungry is the strategy. Everyone has an opinion but until we see what Dallas gets from the two draft picks this conclusion is null. I’m counting on them beefing up the defense hopefully not another route. Key statement and research for your next post. Defensive First round draft availability. Have a great day.

Scott
Scott
Oct 24, 2025 1:13 PM
Reply to  Cano

Let me explain this to you like you’re a five year old, since that’s the level of maturity you’re demonstrating here – talking to people like this makes you a douche. You are a giant, flaming douchebag, and you need to grow up and learn how to speak respectfully if you want to participate in conversations with the adults. Okay, child?

Shiraz
Shiraz
Oct 17, 2025 5:32 PM

Mike is right. Silly premature conclusion when the two 1st round picks haven’t even been used. If the land two outstanding all-pros say hypothetically, then what are you going to say? Come back and change your article? But hey I get it, enjoy the clicks and views while you still can capitalize on knee jerk conclusions.

Mrantmar
Mrantmar
Oct 18, 2025 7:48 AM

Or if Cdee doesn’t drop a few passes they beat Philly – should have beat GB somehow after hanging 40 on a MP led defense – the media sure got quiet about GB and Jerry after that. Then the ugly Carolina game – was that really the defenses fault ? The offense stalled in 2nd half. So without the great hall of fame SB maker in MP the boys are a few plays away from being a one loss team. And that’s with a total garbage DC calling plays. They are a worse team because of the DC not the MP trade.

Oran
Oran
Oct 18, 2025 4:04 PM

Making better could mean financial, locker room, not just the score board.

Charlie
Charlie
Oct 17, 2025 7:54 PM

Yeah if they kept Parsons they are a top 5 defense…. oh wait…. with him last year they sucked. He is a great player but he hasnt really made a big difference in team #s at all. GB has one more sack(u know parsons didbt deserve that sack) yhan the cowboys after the cowboys gave them there best pass rusher, that doesnt sound like micah has made that much differnce yet. honestly as far as Dallas is from REAL contention I’m ok with JJ shedding a HUGE contract and getting back 2 first rounders toward what is honestly a much needed defensive rebuild

Mrantmar
Mrantmar
Oct 18, 2025 7:58 AM

I would say your correct on that. The fans serious effort to believe this team was a division winner – and that was before the trade. The trade made perfect sense to me. Remember Zeke when he ran off to Jamaica- should have traded him. Tyron , guaranteed hold in the 4th qtr, Smith should have gotten rid of him. Dak for that matter – he’s a lot like MP – great regular season stat player – big games and the playoffs – cant get it done. Another richer Tony Romo. Maybe a bit more durable. They really should consider trading Dak and Cdee – it’s rebuild mode – this team is going nowhere. Even if by miracle they make the playoffs it will be a blowout loss.

Oran
Oran
Oct 18, 2025 4:15 PM
Reply to  Mrantmar

Tony Romo wins the SB Dak’s rookie year with Ezekial. Tony Romo probably plays in SB if refs don’t cheat Dez catch. Dallas can build a roster they just make decisions at times that sets them back. Dak will perform in the playoffs going forward.

Scott
Scott
Oct 24, 2025 1:26 PM
Reply to  Mike

And you need to take Jerry’s dick out of your mouth. I’m sure you have bills to pay but have some dignity.

James Vargas
James Vargas
Oct 17, 2025 8:16 AM

It is still too early to know the outcome of the trade. But it seems though, Jerry Jones got fleeced as always. In what world do you trade your best defensive player ?

Anthony
Anthony
Oct 18, 2025 6:35 AM
Reply to  James Vargas

In a world where he can’t stop the run and he dissappear s in the playoffs. Team s just started running right at him and it worked. Now this offense is so good they need to be in all in win now mode and this move is better for the future possibly. The 2 first and what they do with the cap.space they created determines the trade but yes this trade made this years team worse but they weren’t good anyways.

Scott
Scott
Oct 24, 2025 1:16 PM
Reply to  Anthony

Ugh, people like you are the worst thing about fandom. “Fans” who just talk themselves into supporting whatever dumb things the team does are like battered women talking themselves into why their husband isn’t so bad.

VAM
VAM
Oct 17, 2025 10:53 AM

IMO, that “sack” MP got credit for of DP wasn’t a sack, b/c it wasn’t done BEHIND the LOS. In an interview after that game, when DP was told he was “sacked” by MP, he was surprised, then laughed, b/c he knew he wasn’t “sacked”.

So, I’m looking at 11 sacks for GB vs 10 sacks for the Cowboys. MP has eleven tackles in five games? So, he has just over two tackles per game. IDK, to me, nothing shattering there.

The outcome of the trade will not be seen for years. Those two first round draft picks and how they perform in the future will weigh heavily on which team actually “won” this trade.

stephen
stephen
Oct 17, 2025 1:49 PM

He’s always drawn extra blocker and still got sacks. He’s not himself, he’s hurt imo, he can drive through like he has int he past

DubBe
DubBe
Oct 17, 2025 2:56 PM

I just can’t believe we’re back to this again. Consider this:

  1. The deal is done
  2. The season is not over
  3. the Cowboys are 1 game back of GB
  4. Micah had 2.5 sacks; James Houston has 3.5
  5. We have not used a single 1st round pick we got in the trade

Yet, we’re handing out “Grade”?

Oran
Oran
Oct 18, 2025 4:36 PM
Reply to  DubBe

They will milk this topic.

Scott
Scott
Oct 24, 2025 1:19 PM
Reply to  Oran

So we’re supposed to just forget about the dumbest trade in franchise history after a few weeks? We are wasting the #1 offense in the league because our defense isn’t even mid-level, kind of seems like that makes it relevant, huh? Seriously, “fans” like this are the most annoying part of supporting anything. It’s not your job to convince yourself that whatever the team did was somehow the right thing, you are not a battered woman and Jerry can’t hurt you.

Siempre
Siempre
Oct 17, 2025 4:12 PM

Parsons is doing zero for Green Bay and would be of zero use for Dallas. Parsons stands on the GB sidelines a lot watching the core defense. he cannot play against the run. So, No..Parsons would not be helping Dallas. Move on from the Parsons hype .Right now Parsons is ranking below #40 as a pass rusher and complaining about officials. he contributed 3 assists , no primary tackles and nothing else last week. If not for media hype, no one would notice Parsons.

DubBe
DubBe
Oct 18, 2025 6:47 AM

Let’s have a real discussion. There are (2) ways to play defense:

  1. The rush gets home fast, that the coverage doesn’t have to hold up long
  2. The coverage hold up long, that it allows enough time for the rush to get home

By trading Micah, the Cowboys have chosen #2. And right not, #2 is being betrayed by this DC because he’s calling 90%+ zone with man coverage personnel.

If Micah was here, I’d be just the same complaint. Dallas being closer to last that 1st, just means that they are 3rd.

To be real, if this team is 5-6-1 or 6-5-1 with 6 games to go, they have a chance.

Oran
Oran
Oct 18, 2025 4:46 PM
Reply to  DubBe

These guys are professional and have been playing football college to pros several years. No one can make me believe the DC is at fault. If you’re not smart enough to get a better understanding of assignments from Monday to Friday you shouldn’t be on the field.

Mrantmar
Mrantmar
Oct 18, 2025 7:40 AM

Keeping Micah Dallas loses – so they had to deal him. Therefore they won already. They could not have signed him with the current Dak, CDee contracts- it’s simple math. Add in the facts – MP cant stop the run, proven during his time in Dallas, no showed in the big games and the 2 playoff games proven again. Anyone can just guess at the future – my guess GB gets run all over in a playoff game they lose and MP is a non factor. Dallas couldnt keep him – now the guy is crying about the officials – Dallas won this deal – yes their defense is worse without him but not 43mil per year worse plus add in who you cant sign going forward and the fact this current roster isn’t winning a SB with or without him. Get rid of Eberflus, get a real DC and then let’s see what it looks like. Dallas and Jerry won this one.

Scott
Scott
Oct 24, 2025 1:22 PM
Reply to  Mrantmar

“Keeping Micah Dallas loses – so they had to deal him. Therefore they won already.”

That has to be the single worst take I have ever read

Pete
Pete
Oct 18, 2025 11:16 AM

So far Green Bay has been fleeced! 188 million, are you kidding me, for what?

Parsons was “found out” many times last year when teams ran at him and he was fully exposed in the playoff game between these two clubs. Parsons was a no show non-factor. He was actually embarrassing!

What has he done this year for his 188? 6 games, basically nothing.

They lost to Cleveland, tied Dallas. Cleveland, Dallas!! Two NFL powerhouses.

Getting rid of Parsons freed up Dallas some serious cap space, got two picks. A steal!

The trade isn’t going to help Dallas this year, they lost so many free agents and Jerrah whiffed on Mazi, add injuries, a 10 sack season from Parsons would have been gum on the dam.

Advantage: Dallas

Pete
Pete
Oct 19, 2025 11:56 PM

You believed the defense would be better?

Seriously? SERIOUSLY?

Scott
Scott
Oct 24, 2025 1:20 PM
Reply to  Pete

He’s saying that’s how JJ sold the trade, genius. Reading comprehension is not your strength, huh?

David
David
Oct 18, 2025 2:49 PM

This text has a strong opinion-biased smell rather than the objective rigour that it tries to sell. It is not factoring in so many variables, like the facts that there is a new DC, a new scheme, injuries, a non existent passrush not because there is none but because throws are being made so fast given the zone defense, etc etc etc. I don’t see how biased negative interpretations help the conversation or an objective evaluation. There is no way of knowing the final balance yet because there are many variables still in the air, like the ones I just mentioned or like the huge fact that there are still precious draft picks in the equation that won’t give results until a couple of years down the road. If you have an opinion that’s fine, if you try to sell it as an objective study when it’s clearly not the case, then that’s just poor journalism, you can do better.

Oran
Oran
Oct 18, 2025 4:00 PM

Not having to pay for a guy that was motivated by money top dollar while getting specialist production is a win for Dallas. Besides the former player was attempting to start the season injured. Getting that attitude away from players ready to perform in 2025 is a win in Dallas. A few nuances and not just stats should be considered.

Jason
Jason
Oct 18, 2025 4:11 PM

4 first rounders in the next 2 years added to this team could do wonders for this roster if y’all hit on the picks look out.

james
james
Oct 18, 2025 4:28 PM

Worst trade ever…. gave up a 25 yr old pass rusher for late round picks….strictly ego got in the way

Derp
Derp
Oct 18, 2025 10:03 PM

Jerry jones is a jackass

Daniel
Daniel
Oct 18, 2025 11:09 PM

Trade was amazing for cowboys. First round draft picks are gold. You can lock up a stud for 5 years without paying too much. Even if they got nothing but those 2 picks they won the trade. They got rid of a huge salary and have years of multiple first round picks. It’s exactly what the lions did with Stafford a few years ago and look at where they are now.
This trade has the potential to pay big dividends for the next 6 to 7 years with young talent on low salaries

Cam da fan
Cam da fan
Oct 18, 2025 11:18 PM

This writer….obviously a Packers fan. Mica was a decent end for Dallas but any top 10 o-line would shut him down, especially when the game really mattered. only time will tell. but even with parsons, the cowboys would probably have the same record at this point in the season. i think their d will get better as a unit, hopefully before its too late for this season.

Pete
Pete
Oct 20, 2025 12:06 AM

Yeah, they won, from behind all day to that powerhouse, Arizona. Who was Arizonas QB? Just sayin!

Matt
Matt
Oct 20, 2025 12:32 AM

Actually 3, by the time the game was done. First game w/3 sacks in his career. Considering the sack numbers above, after a slow-ish start, seems like Parsons is just “regressing to the mean” (which bolsters your argument.)

Zeke
Zeke
Oct 21, 2025 9:54 AM

If they end up with one or two stud with that pick from Green Bay. Stay draft one guy or move back in draft two. If you hit on them and they help build your team more complete and able to beat good to great teams. Than the trade will be a hit. Parson didn’t help us get pass top nfl teams. He just didn’t. Not a one men game, as we know but if you hasn’t shown you put us in place to beat those team why make you the highest paid players at your position, almost QB money.

ABQCowboy
ABQCowboy
Oct 21, 2025 10:46 AM

It’s like being married and divorced sometimes. Sometimes, divorce isn’t really what you want but sometimes, you don’t have a choice in the deal. Sometimes the decision rests with the other party. This is the case, IMO, with Micah. Parsons could have stayed but he elected to move on. You can poll this any way you want but at the end of the day, Parsons could have stayed. The agent works for Parsons, not the other way around. He could have stayed, he decided to leave.

Why are we crying over this still? As many have stated, we won’t know the score on this deal till the picks are in and we definitely won’t know the score for GB until they get into the playoffs and need Micah to show up and be a difference maker. That’s when you need great players to show up and that’s something we really didn’t see in Dallas with Parsons.

Dallas Cowboys player wearing jersey number 4 sitting on the field with teammates standing around him after injury.
Previous Story

Understanding How Cowboys Matchups Influence Betting Trends

Quarterback throwing a football at AT&T Stadium during a Dallas Cowboys game, dressed in formal suit and tie, highlighting NFL sports and football stadium atmosphere.
Next Story

NFL Legend Tom Brady To Make Highly Anticipated Return At Flag Football Event