What the Cowboys Would Get With Mike Pettine Calling the Defense

Dallas Cowboys defensive consultant and Minnesota Vikings defensive coordinator Brian Flores did not see eye to eye in Minnesota.

Mike Pettine spent eight seasons as an NFL defensive coordinator. Six times his defense finished in the top 10 in yards allowed. Only three of those eight teams finished in the top 10 in points allowed, and the one I’d study if I were the Cowboys is the odd one out.

His 2019 Green Bay Packers finished 18th in yards and ninth in scoring. I could live with Dallas giving up a few first downs if somebody around here could figure out how to make teams kick field goals.

Jerry Jones said Tuesday the Cowboys are discussing Christian Parker’s responsibilities, and if Dallas makes a change before Tennessee, I would give Pettine the headset.

Pettine already helps build the game plan, and Parker knows him well enough from Green Bay that he called Pettine himself to ask for help. That Packers’ connection tells me more about what Dallas might do Sunday than all the talk about Brian Flores.


Minnesota Vikings defensive coordinator staring intensely onto the football field.

What Mike Pettine Actually Did for Brian Flores

“We didn’t see eye to eye on a lot of things.” Pettine said those differences were why he spent his final Vikings season working on offense. He had been in Minnesota since 2022, a year before Flores arrived, and worked on the defense with Flores in 2023 and 2024.

By 2025, they were working on opposite sides of the ball, so calling Pettine an architect of the Minnesota Vikings defense might be a little much.

Where I will give Pettine credit is the outside linebacker room. In 2024, Jonathan Greenard had 12 sacks and Andrew Van Ginkel had 11.5. Van Ginkel also ran back two interceptions for touchdowns.

Minnesota was the only team that season with two players who each had 11.5 sacks. I think that’s a pretty good line on Pettine’s old resume.


Buffalo Bills' head coach Doug Marrone, left, and defensive coordinator Mike Pettine, right, watch the rookie minicamp at the team's NFL football training facility.

Buffalo Tells Me More than the Jets Do

Mike Pettine came up in Baltimore, going from coaching assistant to assistant defensive line coach to coaching outside linebackers. He had that last job on the 2006 Ravens, who allowed a league-low 12.6 points per game.

Rex Ryan coordinated that defense, and when Ryan got the Jets job, he took Pettine with him.

Their first defense in New York was good and only allowed about 312 yards a game, which was 3rd best in the NFL. Ryan called a lot of those plays, but Pettine had plenty of input.

Mike Pettine would call the defense in 2011, and the defense was 5th best in the NFL. The offense was the issue for those teams.

Just to make sure we are all on the same page with Mike Pettine, I would put more stock in what happened when Pettine left Ryan and went to Buffalo.

In one season under Doug Marrone, the Bills went from 22nd to 10th in yards allowed. They sacked quarterbacks 57 times and intercepted 23 passes.

If I’m calling plays against a team that ranks fourth against the pass and 28th against the run, how many times do you think I’m dropping back on first down? Buffalo still finished 20th in points allowed. I would love that for the Cowboys defense.

His worst team defenses came when he was head coach of the Cleveland Browns and those teams in 2014 and 2015 finished 23rd and 27th. Which is still better than what we are seeing with the Cowboys.

After his stint as head coach of the Cleveland Browns, he went back to being a defensive coordinator for the Green Bay Packers in 2018-2020.


Green Bay Packers defensive coordinator Mike Pettine before an NFL football game against the Oakland Raiders in Green Bay.

How Green Bay Played Six Defensive Backs

In Green Bay, Pettine liked putting two defenders up close, one on either side of the center. Not something we are used to seeing in Dallas.

The center would have to figure out protection before he knew which one was coming, and sometimes both backed out. Or you could have watched Za’Darius Smith move inside, making the guard block a guy he’d been watching a tackle deal with.

Green Bay would use six defensive backs on nearly half its snaps in 2019 and cut its points allowed from 25 per game to 19.6. They would end up finishing18th in yards both years.

Then the NFC championship game happened against none other than the San Francisco 49ers, who ran for 285 yards against Green Bay. Doesn’t that sound familiar?

Jimmy Garappolo only had to throw eight passes because they knew Pettine’s weakness has always been stopping the run, but if we can get better against the pass, us Cowboys fans are used to giving up the run.

So, I say Jerry Jones needs to give Pettine the rest of the season with Christian Parker still helping to build the weekly plans and learning better in game management.

Was this helpful?

Cody Warren is a sports journalist at InsideTheStar.com, where he has published 302 articles reaching over 1 million readers. He is a Law Enforcement Officer with nearly 20 years of professional service across multiple assignments, bringing investigative rigor and a commitment to factual accuracy to his Dallas Cowboys coverage.

Dallas Cowboys football team logo and branding, promoting free Cowboys news app for fans.

Comments

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Loading comments…
Dark
Light