PFF grades and coverage data reveal four fixes—personnel and scheme—that can rescue Matt Eberflus’ struggling Dallas Cowboys defense right now.
A Defense Built on Sand
For six weeks, the Dallas Cowboys’ defense has become a case study in underachievement.
Despite boasting one of the most talented rosters in football, Dallas ranks near the bottom of the league in EPA per dropback allowed (+0.32). On paper, this unit has playmakers at every level. On film and in data, it’s a defense fighting against itself.
This isn’t a talent problem — it’s an identity problem. Matt Eberflus’ defensive structure has grown predictable, leaning on static zone shells that invite easy completions and neutralize the aggression that once defined Dallas.
The Cowboys have the personnel to dictate matchups, yet they’re being dictated to — and the analytics prove it.
The Numbers Behind the Collapse
Dallas’ efficiency data paints a troubling picture. The Cowboys run Cover 2 on 29 percent and Cover 3 on 35 percent of snaps.
Nearly two-thirds of their plays rely on conservative zone looks designed to prevent explosives — but instead, it’s producing a slow bleed of short gains.
Linebackers Kenneth Murray Jr. and Marist Liufau have been exposed in coverage, posting PFF defensive grades of 39.3 and 41.1.
Both are built to attack downhill, not carry routes through deep zones. Offenses exploit that mismatch with play-action and quick seams, leading to one of the league’s highest completion rates against linebackers.
It’s schematic rigidity, not a lack of effort, that’s sinking this defense.
Miscast Talent: Man Corners in Zone Hell
The secondary tells the same story. The Cowboys’ cornerbacks are built for man coverage, yet they’re trapped in zone assignments.
Trevon Diggs, one of the NFL’s premier ballhawks, owns a 62.5 coverage grade, but rarely gets to press receivers.
Kaiir Elam carries a 55.5 coverage grade with a 74.1 run-defense score, while DaRon Bland sits at 61.9, yet spends most snaps spot-dropping into space.
As Mark Bullock’s defensive analysis showed last year, Dallas corners thrive when allowed to challenge receivers and disrupt timing.
Under Eberflus, they’re reacting instead of attacking — and when press corners become space-spotters, their greatest weapon — aggression — vanishes.
The Front Is Winning, but the Scheme Neutralizes It
Ironically, the front four is doing its job. James Houston carries an 80.1 pass-rush grade, ranking among the NFL’s top 30 edge defenders.
Rookie Donovan Ezeiruaku owns a 72.0 overall grade and a 93.7 coverage mark, proving he’s a versatile modern hybrid.
Veteran Dante Fowler Jr. continues to produce with a 74.8 grade, and Osa Odighizuwa anchors the interior at 69.4.
Yet, quarterbacks facing Dallas release the ball in just 2.4 seconds, the fastest in football per Next Gen Stats.
That’s not a failure of the rush — it’s a failure of coverage. The Cowboys’ soft zones invite quick throws that neutralize their line before pressure can arrive.
Eberflus’ defense “trades chaos for control,” and that control is strangling Dallas’ aggression.
Four Data-Driven Fixes to Save the Defense
The data also reveals a path forward if Dallas is willing to adapt.
First, the Cowboys must play more man coverage.
They rank among the league’s lowest in man-coverage rate, but teams like the Vikings and Broncos have shown that aggressive Cover 1 and 2-Man structures still work in 2025.
Second, Donovan Ezeiruaku deserves a larger role. His 93.7 coverage grade shows awareness beyond his years. Pairing him with Houston in nickel fronts gives Eberflus two edges who can pressure or drop, restoring disguise to the pass rush.
Third, Kenneth Murray Jr. should yield to rookie Shemar James. Murray’s 39.3 grade ranks near the bottom of all linebackers, while James (52.6 DEF, 58.0 COV) offers quicker reads and cleaner tackling.
Revenge of the Birds’ breakdown of Nick Rallis’ coverage concepts shows how modern defenses rely on fast, reactive linebackers — a role James can fill immediately.
Finally, with Malik Hooker injured, Dallas must rebuild its safety tandem. Markquese Bell, graded 68.7 overall with a 66.0 coverage mark by PFF, has quietly been one of the team’s most dependable defenders.
His range and tackling make him an ideal replacement for Donovan Wilson in the box. Sliding Juanyeh Thomas (57.5 coverage grade) deep restores communication and balance.
The Path Forward
The Cowboys don’t need a roster overhaul — they need realignment.
The film and PFF analytics agree: this defense has elite talent miscast in a conservative structure.
If Eberflus leans into man coverage, expands Ezeiruaku’s snaps, starts Shemar James, and commits to the Bell–Thomas duo, Dallas can climb from liability to asset before the season ends.
Elite units aren’t defined by stars but by fit and flexibility. The Cowboys have both — they need a scheme that lets it show.
Dallas has the tools to be elite again. It just needs a philosophy that finally matches its personnel.
I’ve been saying this exact same thing for weeks now!! And it took PFF 6 weeks to figure it out!? That’s crazy!! But obviously, I agree, Eberflus needs to quit being stubborn and change his scheme!!
PFF didn’t figure it out, there stats helped figure it out.
You and a thousand other couch GMs have said this here have some flowers…
Right now I trust the couch GMs over the entire Cowboys front office…
excellent article. Now finish it with the only real fix: fire Eburflus.
Amen.
Who said the Dallas defense has talent? Who’s the star & impact player? Kenny that’s about it lbs