I know Brandon Aiyuk in a Cowboys uniform would look pretty darn good at first glance.
If you put him beside CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens, it would give the Cowboys three wide receivers who all win in different ways. Dak Prescott would have options for days all over the field.
Brian Schottenheimer could draw up some pretty crazy plays with those three lined up, and all I would be able to say to an opposing defense is, in my best bad guy from the movie Taken voice is, “Good luck.”
However, that may be the easy part.
The problem I see is Dallas would also be taking on a large contract, and enough off-field foolishness to make Antonio Brown almost seem normal.
There is a 21% chance that Aiyuk gets traded or signs with Dallas, according to the Polymarket App.
Imagine having CeeDee x Pickens x Aiyuk 👀
That’s where I would start slowly rolling up the windows and locking the doors.
The Skill Set Fits
Brandon Aiyuk would not be traded to Dallas to come in and copy Lamb and Pickens. That’s just not what’s needed.
CeeDee Lamb is the centerpiece of the receivers. We have all watched him for years move around the formation, win underneath, and turn a short catch into a chunk play.
George Pickens is the physical outside threat for Dallas. He can stretch the field, make the contested catch look easy, and keep safeties from creeping up too far.
I think Brandon Aiyuk would fit between those two very well.
Aiyuk’s route running is cleaner than Pickens’, and he creates separation which helps not to make every catch a wrestling match. If a defense shades outside on Lamb and Pickens, then Aiyuk works the middle. Stay balanced, and Dak will find whoever gets open first.
On the field, this makes plenty of sense.
Brandon Aiyuk Could Help Lamb and Pickens
I think this could be the biggest football benefit.
We have all watched CeeDee Lamb get most of the attention from every defense Dallas faces. Adding another polished receiver would make a defenses job harder bracketing him all game.
George Pickens makes the defense respect the outside threat and is the perfect compliment to Lamb, but adding Aiyuk would give Dallas another player who can win quickly and punish softer coverage.
That third threat would leave Lamb and Pickens with cleaner matchups, which I think would be bad news for the rest of the league.
At least until…
Brandon Aiyuk Has Burned Every Bridge in Sight
We have all seen the headlines about Aiyuk and his crazy antics on social media.
His situation with the 49ers didn’t end with a normal contract disagreement. San Francisco reportedly voided his 2026 guarantees after he missed required rehabilitation work, and he later landed on the reserve/left squad list.
Then, like everyone nowadays, he went to social media, and we all know that makes everything better, right?
Aiyuk took shots at the organization, John Lynch, Kyle Shanahan, and his former agent. The funniest part of this ordeal was that he publicly pushed wanting to go to Washington, then turned around and stirred up trouble with their starting quarterback, Jayden Daniels.
Jayden Daniels and Brandon Aiyuk are former teammates at Arizona State, so maybe it was just playful back and forth, but it seemed like more to me. Why take jabs at the quarterback you want to play with?
It doesn’t make sense to me.
At some point when a relationship goes up in flames, you have to look at the guy carrying the gas can. In this case, that is undoubtedly Brandon Aiyuk.
Maybe a fresh start fixes him, but I wouldn’t bet valuable picks and a boatload of money on it.
Dallas Has Bigger Needs
If it were me and I knew I was going to take on a headache and possible media backlash, I would go after a position of need like cornerback and Terrion Arnold.
The Cowboys have Lamb, Pickens, KaVontae Turpin, and a soon-to-be breakout player in Ryan Flournoy at wide receiver. That is enough talent to win with.
Other needs are offensive line depth, and the defensive front still has question marks when it comes to the pass rush.
Brandon Aiyuk might make the offense prettier, but that doesn’t mean it is smart roster building. Chemistry plays a major part in roster construction and Aiyuk is a headcase.
To even bring him to Dallas, they would have to give up something valuable and then squeeze another expensive contract into the books.
In my humble opinion, that is a lot to spend on a position that is already in good shape.
Was this helpful?
Comments