Defensive Collapse & Personnel Fixes: Can Matt Eberflus Turn It Around?

1 month ago
5 mins read
Matt Eberflus in Cowboys sweatshirt on field
ARLINGTON, TEXAS - AUGUST 22: Dallas Cowboys defensive coordinator Matt Eberflus walks on the field prior to the NFL Preseason 2025 game against the Atlanta Falcons at AT&T Stadium on August 22, 2025 in Arlington, Texas. (Photo by Sam Hodde/Getty Images)

There is little that hurts Dallas Cowboys fans more than seeing their once-excellent defense, which had been the centerpiece of the company, fall under the pressure of its own expectations.

Dallas was being billed as a defensive powerhouse, headed into the 2025 season. Having well-established playmakers on both ends of the line, a deep rotation of linebackers and a secondary full of athleticism, this was to be the team that would hold the Cowboys’ Super Bowl hopes together.

Instead, the inconsistency, bad tackling and blown assignments have marred the first six weeks of the season, turning sure-win games into frustrating losses.

With these increased questions, Defensive Coordinator Matt Eberflus is under strain to demonstrate that his system is adaptable.

Jerry Jones, the Cowboys owner, has publicly supported the team, stating that the club will remain stable and improve rather than make a reactionary decision. However, one can plainly feel the pressure mounting under the surface.

Eberflus has a challenging task not only of sewing holes, but of restoring confidence and recovering the stern violence of discipline that was formerly at the core of this defense.

It is not about whether Dallas has the talent; it’s about whether it can play as a team again.

To the fans and analysts tracking all the events, debating possible roster changes and coaching ideologies is just as heated as the playing stakes themselves. It is no less intense than the analysis and strategic reasoning on No Deposit Bonus casino situations for players worldwide, where risk and reward depend on time and action.

What Went Wrong on Defense

The downfall of the Cowboys is not based on a single factor but a set of systemic failures.

With his attention to detail, Eberflus has not been able to adapt to the pace and innovativeness of the offenses of his rivals, which are heavy on zone. Quarterbacks have shredded the middle of the field by finding softer areas and leaving linebackers with little to do but drop into coverage.

The once unmerciful pass rush no longer has its sting, and it is not always successful in getting after high-end signal-callers.

Moreover, the problem has been aggravated by missed tackles, making what should have been short gains into explosive plays.

On its side, the run defense, once a strength, has been torn asunder by teams that set an early pace and keep Dallas out of sync. The lack of communication in the secondary is, perhaps, the most troublesome aspect.

The poorly-planned coverage and missed rotations have resulted in expensive failures, even for Pro Bowl-level talents.

Furthermore, the philosophy of Eberflus’s defense is based on discipline, hard work, and execution. The breakdown of those fundamentals causes the collapse of the system.

Players seem to be uncertain about who they are supposed to play and are more reactive than proactive.

The outcome is a defense that seems more defensive than offensive; a complete antithesis of the swagger that characterized Dallas’ defense over the last couple of seasons.

Human Resource Problems and the Way to Rectify

The Cowboys should determine whether the scheme or both the personnel and the scheme are to blame in order to remedy this defense.

Injuries have been involved and some of the key players have been out of action. The depth, particularly at the linebacker and safety level, has been put to the test. The young players have demonstrated potential but do not possess the consistency to drive a leading defense.

Moreover, the next trade deadline will enable Dallas to make crucial changes to the roster. An old hand in the secondary may be able to stabilize communication and leadership, and an interior lineman who can block running lanes may bring balance to the front seven.

In addition to acquisitions, internal development is essential. Eberflus will need to find a way to involve more of his stars and place them in situations that allow their instincts to take over, rather than limiting them to strict frameworks.

It might be essential to modify the scheme to focus on versatility.

The addition of man coverage, hybrid formations, and disguised blitzes would assist Dallas in creating turnovers and disrupting the opposing quarterbacks.

The Cowboys have traditionally played on momentum and energy; regaining that advantage might mean that Eberflus has to give up some control and allow his players the creativity to be creative.

Leadership Under the Microscope

There is a burden attached to coaching defense in Dallas that would be difficult to find in many other jobs in the NFL. The demands are great, and time is short.

Eberflus, a man whom the Cowboys hired due to his reputation as a defensive strategist and motivator, is now being tested as a leader and a tactician.

His organizational skill in getting the locker room behind him will determine his tenure as much as his play-calling.

According to reports made within the organization, Eberflus has not lost the room, but players are seeking greater accountability and a clearer direction. The veterans are reported to have participated more in film sessions and practice leadership, which is a good indication that the locker room is not divided.

Nevertheless, as long as there is no observable change to the action on the field, morale will continue to decline.

The next few matches are a kind of crossroads — not only for the Cowboys’ season but also for Eberflus’s reputation as a defensive coordinator who can withstand the storm.

Can Eberflus Turn It Around?

The positive that Dallas can focus on right now is that the season has not been lost. The talent cannot be ignored, and the situation in the NFC provides an opportunity for the Cowboys defense to recover.

At this point, a relatively small number of statement performances would help to change the story and regain trust, not only in the locker room but also among the fan base.

To that end, however, Eberflus must be adaptable.

The minds most effective in defenses today in the NFL are those that are flexible in their approach to the game, devising plans to attack based on the specific traits of their personnel and opponents rather than a system of rigidity and inflexibility.

Provided that Eberflus can streamline the work, close the communication gaps, and jump-start the pass rush, Dallas still has the potential to prove themselves a playoff contender.

The fall of the defense has been melodramatic, but so might be the recovery. It is all about execution, trust and timing.

Bryson Treece

Bryson Treece

I’m Bryson Treece, founder and managing editor of InsideTheStar.com and DailyRivals.net, where I’ve covered the Dallas Cowboys and other sporting topics since 2009 with a focus on accuracy, analysis, and the fan perspective. Over more than fifteen years of writing, research, and community interaction, I’ve built ITS into a trusted independent source for thoughtful Cowboys coverage. Based in Greenville, Texas, my goal has always been to inform, entertain, and connect fans who share the same passion for America’s Team. Connect with @CowboysNation on X/Twitter to join the conversation.

Dallas Cowboys rookie football players in action during a game, showcasing team play, defensive and offensive strategies, and game intensity on the field.
Previous Story

Booker’s solid return after 3 weeks away leads effort by rookies

High-energy Dallas Cowboys player celebrating during an NFL game, wearing #98 jersey, blue and white uniform, with a crowd and referee in the background.
Next Story

1 Titan of a Trade to Fix a Terrible Cowboys’ Defense